Glasgow Warriors v Edinburgh: Key clashes and where 1872 Cup first leg will be won and lost

It’s an old fixture but there’s a new man at the helm for one of the protagonists as Edinburgh’s Mike Blair makes his bow in the 1872 Cup as a head coach against Glasgow Warriors at Scotstoun on Monday.

Rory Darge has excelled since moving to Glasgow Warriors from Edinburgh. (Photo by Ross MacDonald / SNS Group)
Rory Darge has excelled since moving to Glasgow Warriors from Edinburgh. (Photo by Ross MacDonald / SNS Group)

Blair has experienced this derby as a player with Edinburgh and an assistant coach with Glasgow so is well versed in the intricacies of an occasion which can sometimes boil over.

Danny Wilson, the Warriors chief, got the better of Blair’s predecessor Richard Cockerill, winning four of the six derbies that were played from August 2020 to May 2021 as Covid led to an increase in localised fixtures.

Sign up to our Rugby Union newsletter

Festive bonhomie is usually left at the door when these sides meet and both coaches know that winning the physical battle is key to gaining the upper hand.

Ali Price helped guide Glasgow to a European Champions Cup victory over Exeter Chiefs at a misty Scotstoun. (Photo by Craig Williamson / SNS Group)

Where the game will be won and lost

The two teams have rightly won plaudits for their attacking rugby this season but they also showed their harder edge in the lead up to this derby during eye-catching European victories. Edinburgh’s away win at Saracens and Glasgow’s defeat of Exeter Chiefs at Scotstoun were achieved with robust, courageous performances in which the Scottish sides outfought and outthought more illustrious opponents.

Jim Hamilton, the former Scotland lock who will cover the game for Premier Sports, spoke last week about getting the fundamentals right: scrum, lineout drive, defence and kicking game. Wilson agreed and also stressed the need to come out on top at the breakdown.

“The first thing is physicality,” said the Glasgow coach. “In these big games you have to win the physical battle, and that’s the gainline battle both sides of the ball.

Henry Pyrgos will captain Edinburgh against Glasgow at Scotstoun. (Photo by Paul Devlin / SNS Group)

“In attack we need to carry, we need to go forward, and our breakdown needs to be extremely quick for us to be able to play the way we want to. And likewise in defence: we need to win collisions on the gainline, which I thought we did brilliantly against Exeter.

“Against a massive team, our work on the breakdown in defence was at a top level – and it will have to be again in the derby.

“Some derbies can be scrappy and messy – the last couple have been really exciting games of rugby, I think, and you’ve seen plenty of tries. The way they’re playing at the moment and the way we’ve always played, really, is a match-up for quite an exciting game of rugby. We’ll see.

“So there’s the first port of call for both teams. You’ll also see an interesting set-piece battle, because the teams and individuals know each other well.”

Edinburgh's Hamish Watson was voted player of the Six Nations last season. (Photo by Paul Devlin / SNS Group)

Key clashes

With the Six Nations just around the corner, the 1872 Cup games offer some mouthwatering positional match-ups, none more so than at openside flanker where Glasgow’s young pretender Rory Darge takes on last year’s player of the championship, Hamish Watson.

Darge has been a revelation since moving from Edinburgh last spring and Wilson is intrigued to see how he fares against his former team-mate.

“I think he knows that there’s a big challenge ahead of him now he’s going head to head with an outstanding No 7 in Hamish Watson,” said the Glasgow coach. “For him to play against not only Edinburgh but against Hamish makes for quite a clash, and I think it will be a great battle – a young man coming through versus a very experienced international. It makes for another sub-plot in what already has plenty head-to-heads.”

Read More

Read More
Teams revealed for Glasgow Warriors v Edinburgh Rugby 1872 Cup clash

Scrum-half offers another fascinating duel. Edinburgh’s team selection has been shaped largely by who is available, with Covid and injuries limiting Blair’s options, but the decision to pick Henry Pyrgos ahead of Ben Vellacott as starting nine appears tactical.

Vellacott has been outstanding since moving to the capital in the summer and his pace would trouble any side but the experienced Pyrgos is adept at game management and it’s a measure of the esteem in which he is held by Blair that he is named as skipper against Glasgow ahead of regular co-captain Stuart McInally.

“Henry has done really well the last couple of games off the bench,” said Blair, who is likely to utilise Vellacott during the second half. “It is in line with what I’ve done with other positions in that I want to breed competition and give players opportunities as well.

“I also thought Ben did a great job off the bench against Zebre, adding some pace to the game, so it is just a bit of balance with what we’re trying to do. I think they’ve both got real strengths to their game and hopefully this way round we’ll see the best of both of them.”

Different gravy: why the 1872 Cup is special

While the Covid disruptions of 2020-21 and the decision to extend the season with the Rainbow Cup led to a proliferation of derbies – six Edinburgh-Glasgow games in nine months – the current campaign has seen the 1872 Cup revert to a two-game aggregate format. It’s a decision that restores its immediacy and gives it back its place as a competition settled over the festive period.

Scotstoun would have been a sell-out and Edinburgh were expecting a crowd of around 30,000 for the second leg on January 2. Unfortunately, both games will be played in all but empty stadiums after the Scottish Government imposed restrictions of 500 on all outdoor sporting events.

The local dust-up isn’t always viewed fondly – ex-Edinburgh boss Cockerill used to refer to the trophy as the “gravy bowl”, Darcy Graham revealed last week – but there’s no denying its popularity with the supporters. It’s just a shame none will be there to see it.

Get a year of unlimited access to all The Scotsman's sport coverage without the need for a full subscription. Expert analysis of the biggest games, exclusive interviews, live blogs, transfer news and 70 per cent fewer ads on - all for less than £1 a week. Subscribe to us today


Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.