New catch pit to contain A83 Rest and Be Thankful landslides completed – but campaigners dismiss it as ‘Band-Aid solution’

A fifth giant “catch pit" as part of the ongoing battle to prevent landslides blocking the A83 Rest and Be Thankful pass in Argyll has been completed, it was announced today.

However, campaigners were pessimistic about the worth of the £1.1 million defensive hole, which they described as a Band-Aid solution while repeating calls for a replacement road to be accelerated.

BEAR Scotland, which maintains the trunk road to Kintyre for Transport Scotland, said it would add “resilience” to the route, which has been forced to close by a series of landslides.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

The 120m-long pit, which was completed last week after being started last September, is 12m wide and can hold some 4,500 tonnes of debris – the size of an Olympic swimming poll.

The new catch pit is one of a series beside the A83 designed to prevent landslide debris reaching the road. Picture: BEAR Scotland

Work started after a major landslip blocked the A83 in August last year.

It is the latest of a series of catch pits, with a total capacity of nearly 20,000 tonnes, which have been excavated beside the A83 so rocks and soil fall into them before reaching the road.

Measures to shore up the steep hillside above the road are continuing, with a further catch pit to be added at the site of landslips last year.

Five options are being considered for a replacement road on the other side of Glen Croe, costing up to £860m and likely to take up to ten years to complete.

The catch pits in May. Picture: John Devlin

Transport minister Graeme Dey said: “Improving the resilience of the A83 Rest and Be Thankful (RABT) is one of our top priorities, so the completion of this additional catch pit is very welcome.

“The Scottish Government continues to treat the issue with the seriousness and urgency it deserves, as we look to implement measures to maintain connectivity on a short, medium and long term basis.”

BEAR Scotland north west representative Eddie Ross said: “The completion of another catch-pit at the Rest and Be Thankful is another step forward in strengthening the landslide mitigation measures for the A83.”

Read More

Read More
Insight: A83 Rest and Be Thankful's last line of defence in Scotland's latest ba...

However, John Gurr, chairperson at the RABT Campaign, said: “Over £80m has been spent on mitigation measure over the years and sadly most of those measures have been unsuccessful in keeping the RABT open.

"Last year, despite £1m being spent on mitigation measures just like this one, 20,000 tonnes of debris still fell at the rest and closed the area for over 200 days.

“Our autumn and winter seasons are increasingly wetter, and with 100,00 tonnes of unstable material expected to fall over the coming months, what we need is a permanent fix at the RABT, not a Band-Aid solution which slips off at the first sight of rain.

Dumbarton Labour MSP Jackie Baillie said: “While this new catch pit is welcome, this is the latest in a long line of mitigation measures – and millions of pounds spent – which have all failed to keep the RABT open.

"Last year, despite measures being put in place, the RABT was closed for the majority of the year which hugely disadvantaged the surrounding communities and the local economy.

“We need a lasting solution for the A83 and, in the meantime, we need to consider better interim alternatives so that traffic can keep moving and access to and from Argyll and Bute is maintained.”

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.