'Persuasive' argument to raise proposed assisted dying age limit to 18
The MSP behind proposals to legalise assisted dying in Scotland says there is a “persuasive” case to raise the age limit to 18.
Should Liam McArthur MSP’s bill become law, it would allow an assisted death for all terminally ill, mentally competent adults over the age of 16 - however similar legislation being considered in Westminster would put the age limit to 18.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdLast week a senior Police Scotland officer also raised concerns the lower age limit north of the Border could make Scotland an “attractive place” for people seeking an assisted death.


Mr McArthur was questioned on his bill to legalise assisted dying by Holyrood’s health committee, where he was asked if the age limit should be raised to 18 as the UN convention on the rights of the child applies to 16 and 17 year olds.
He said: “You could make a string of arguments for both.
“The rationale for opting for 16 is that is the age of adult capacity for making medical decisions in Scotland.
“But we’ve also heard evidence from other jurisdictions such as states in Australia and the US where it is 18, and the bill introduced in Westminster has a similar age limit, so I am keen to reflect further should the bill pass at stage one.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad“I think the arguments for setting the age level at 18 are persuasive, but I think the reason for opting for 16 is that’s the age where individuals are deemed to have capacity in relation to their care and treatment.”
The Lib Dem MSP also said it was important to listen to young people’s views on this legislation as they have “very clear personal experience” of watching family members go through bad deaths, and said if the age is increased to 18, these views should be taken into account.
However Mr McArthur added the number of 16 and 17 year olds seeking an assisted death would be “exceptionally low, potentially zero”.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIt is estimated around one per cent of the people who die in a year in Scotland would have an assisted death should this legislation go ahead.
This comes after Assistant Chief Constable Steven Johnson warned the differences between the two assisted dying bills in Holyrood and Westminster could “make Scotland an attractive place to come”, particularly if there is a difference in the age limits.
The Scottish bill also says someone must be “ordinarily resident” in Scotland for 12 months to be eligible for assisted dying, something Mr Johnson says could be problematic and leave police officers with an increased burden on investigations.
However Mr McArthur says he is “fairly comfortable and not concerned” about the legal definition of this in his bill.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdDuring his appearance at the health committee, he said: “‘Ordinarily resident’ is phrased in such a way as to accommodate situations where individuals work outwith Scotland for a period or are on a prolonged holiday, but for all intents and purposes they live in Scotland and are registered with a medical practice here, which is another requirement.
“The terminology is fairly commonly used in the law, but perhaps less so in criminal law where Police Scotland come into contact with this more often.
“I don’t see it as problematic.”
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.