SNP ministers poised to directly intervene in NHS Grampian unless ‘urgent improvements’ by Christmas

The Health Secretary has ordered an external intervention team to support and oversee progress at NHS Grampian

Health Secretary Angela Constance has threatened the new-look NHS Grampian leadership team that ministers could directly intervene in the running of the health board if there is a failure to “evidence urgent improvements” by Christmas.

Ms Constance told MSPs that escalating the board to Stage 5 from the current Stage 4 of measures - which would mean ministers directly take control of the board in the most heightened step of intervention available to the Scottish government - is “on the table”.

The leadership at NHS Grampian’s Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin has been criticised by Healthcare Improvement Scotlandplaceholder image
The leadership at NHS Grampian’s Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin has been criticised by Healthcare Improvement Scotland

The threat comes after a damning report from Health Improvement Scotland (HIS), published last week, warned that patient safety was put at risk in a host of bombshell findings into the leadership of NHS Grampian and specific concerns at Dr Gray’s Hospital in Elgin. Paediatric surgery was suspended at Dr Gray’s in June but HIS warned it had continued until August.

Last month, it was announced that the experienced Professor John Connaghan has been brought in as interim chairman of the NHS Grampian board.

Acute medical director, Paul Bachoo and Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, executive medical director, have left their roles at NHS Grampian in the wake of the report while Dr June Brown, executive nurse director, left in September.

Ms Constance has ordered an external intervention team, made up of senior NHS experts in patient safety and clinical governance, to support and oversee progress at NHS Grampian.

The Health Secretary told MSPs the investigation into NHS Grampian was “distressing” and shed light on “longstanding and systemic” problems with the running of the health board.

Health Secretary Angela Constanceplaceholder image
Health Secretary Angela Constance | PA

Ms Constance told Holyrood that the “chief executive and the interim chair know they have until the end of the year to evidence urgent improvements”.

She added: “NHS Grampian will therefore remain within a strengthened Stage 4 framework, with a new focus directly on patient safety, clinical governance, leadership and delivery of the review's recommendations.

“The option to move to Stage 5 remains, and I will reassess the situation in six weeks’ time.”

The Health Secretary told MSPs that “confidence will have to be rebuilt with ministers” with the new board and leadership team of NHS Grampian.

She added: “I will review the situation with escalation within six weeks.

“All options absolutely remain on the table.”

Scottish Labour health spokesperson, Jackie Baillie, highlighted that the HIS inspection took place in April of this year, claiming that “red flags were raised with the Scottish government’s deputy chief medical officer in May”.

Scottish Labour health spokesperson, Jackie Baillieplaceholder image
Scottish Labour health spokesperson, Jackie Baillie | Getty Images

She added: “Why were ministers not alerted to this in May, given the substantial safety issues at stake?

“Isn’t it beyond belief that those who should be held accountable have all mysteriously left their posts?”

Ms Constance confirmed she was made aware of some of the issues at Dr Gray’s Hospital in August but did not see the HIS report until October 29.

She committed to “outline the government’s engagement over the past year” with NHS Grampian by the end of November.

Scottish Conservative MPS, Tim Eagle, argued that NHS Grampian has been “monitored by the Scottish government since November 2023”.

Scottish Conservative MSP Tim Eagleplaceholder image
Scottish Conservative MSP Tim Eagle | Supplied

He added: “So for three years, it’s been on this government’s watch that NHS Grampian has been failing.”

Asked by Mr Eagle what would stop her escalating NHS Grampian to Stage 5, Ms Constance said: “That will be quite simply if there is a lack of demonstrable progress.”

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice