Campaigners accuse Scottish Government of backtracking over abortion clinic buffer zones

Campaigners have accused the Scottish Government of a climbdown over abortion clinic buffer zones, after a bid for new legislation to protect women from harassment was rejected as a ‘disproportionate’.

Let us know what you think and join the conversation at the bottom of this article.

The Evening News can reveal that Women’s Health Minister, Maree Todd has told Back Off Scotland that legislation to enact buffer zones around clinics providing abortion services in Scotland is ‘not on the cards’ because she fears the Government would face legal proceedings from pro-life groups.

Campaigners, who have called for 150m zones to be created to deter demonstrators, said the government decision is tantamount to a refusal to protect women’s right to privacy and harassment-free healthcare.

Buzzer zones are 'not on the cards' says Maree ToddBuzzer zones are 'not on the cards' says Maree Todd
Buzzer zones are 'not on the cards' says Maree Todd
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Back Off Scotland movement, which started in Edinburgh, warned failure to show national leadership on the issue will result in a postcode lottery of care which will leave vulnerable women exposed to harassment.

Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole Hamilton said the Government ‘dragging it’s heels’ on a national policy over buffer zones is letting women down.

It follows the recently published Women’s Health Plan in which the Scottish Government stated that they would work with NHS and Local Authorities to find “ways of preventing women feeling harassed when accessing abortion care due to protests or vigils.”

Back Off Scotland secured a buffer zone commitment from Edinburgh City Council in February, after reports of harassment outside Chalmers Clinic sparked a petition.

Pro life images projected onto clinicPro life images projected onto clinic
Pro life images projected onto clinic

A survey found that 56 per cent of those visiting the clinic “felt very uncomfortable due to the protesters”.

But a similar bid in Glasgow was thrown out after the council concluded that it does not have the powers to legislate over the issue.

Back Off Scotland co-founder and director, Lucy Grieve said: “It is disappointing that the Scottish Government refuse to use powers they have to protect women across Scotland.

Lucy Grieve said claims legislation would be 'disproportionate' dismissed the harassment faced by women using clinicsLucy Grieve said claims legislation would be 'disproportionate' dismissed the harassment faced by women using clinics
Lucy Grieve said claims legislation would be 'disproportionate' dismissed the harassment faced by women using clinics

"By enacting buffer zones in one local authority area and not others, harassment-free access to healthcare turns into a postcode lottery.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“Abortion is a legal right for all women who need one. If we want to be world-leading, then this is an opportunity to show what Scotland stands for. Bye-laws at local level are simply not enough.”

"Claiming new legislation would be ‘disproportionate’ dismisses the experience of women who have been harassed.”

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP said: “For years my party and I have backed campaigners calling to set up buffer zones. Every patient should be able to receive the medical treatment they need without fear of harassment or intimidation.

"Councils in England have used these zones to protect clinical staff and those attending appointments but local authorities in Scotland need to apply to the Scottish Government.

“The decision by the Scottish Government to drag their feet rather than put forward a national policy to allow buffer zones sets up a postcode lottery and lets women in need down.

"If the Government won’t pursue a national policy, they should give local authorities the ability to respond to local circumstances in setting up these buffer zones, without having to ask SNP ministers for permission."

A Scottish Government spokesperson said:

“Our Programme for Government already includes a commitment to support any local authority who wishes to use bye-laws to establish buffer zones – and we would invite them to do so as the swiftest way to have such zones enacted.”

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habitsbrought about by Coronavirus impacts our advertisers.If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.