Edinburgh Festival concerts to be held right next to homes despite objections
Forty classical musical performances are to be staged right next to residential properties – despite the objections of neighbours concerned about noise and safety.
Let us know what you think and join the conversation at the bottom of this article.
Although the temporary venue has already been built, Edinburgh City Council’s licensing committee has given final approval for a series of classical music concerts to be held on Edinburgh Academy Junior School’s playing fields, as part of the Edinburgh International Festival.
From Saturday August 7 to Sunday August 29, forty performances of classical music will take place on the school’s Arboretum Road campus, with some starting at noon and the later concerts finishing at around 9.45pm.
Previously, the stage and seating arrangements were the subject of a planning application, submitted in April, which attracted more than 20 objections from the surrounding community.
The majority of the complaints related to the impact of noise, and the capacity of the neighbouring site to accommodate parking for up to 670 concert goers at a time.
Rachel Chandler, of Arboretum Road, wrote in her objection: “This will cause considerable noise and disturbance for my baby trying to sleep each evening next to this venue.
“In addition considerable noise and disturbance of people accessing the venue along our residential street and also trying to park in the vicinity.
“This generates lots of traffic and makes our quiet street unsafe for our children and pets.
“This is an astonishing scale – [up to] three shows a day means over 2000 people passing our gate each day and night on a quiet residential street in a conservation area.”
Katherine Cydzik, also of Arboretum Road, wrote: “The hosting of this event is likely to cause the residents of Arboretum Road significant inconvenience for an eight week period.
“It is a residential street, with limited parking restrictions, narrow pavements and is not adequately served by public transport or parking in order to act as a proxy for the Usher Hall, without causing substantial disruption to local residents for a prolonged period.”
Glen Allison, of Inverleith Place, wrote: “As stated in the application this concert formerly took place in a public auditorium suitable for such events – The Usher Hall.
“This is now proposed to take place in a residential area which is also a conservation area.
“It is an open construction (taking up 2957 square meters) and sound/noise will travel.
“The level of noise should be ascertained with a decibel meter. Young children will be asleep from 7pm onwards. Sudden, loud noises can cause distress to animals, children and the elderly. What sound-proofing measures are being taken?”
Despite these objections, in June councillors approved the planning application at a meeting of the council’s development management committee.
Now, the concerts have been given final approval by councillors, this time sitting on the licensing committee, as the Edinburgh International Festival applied for a public entertainment licence.
Appearing at the meeting, Colinton and Fairmilehead Labour councillor Scott Arthur asked council officers whether residents had any chance to formally object to the concerts, other than through the planning application.
Council officers told councillor Arthur that only statutory consultees, such as Police Scotland or SEPA, can formally object to public entertainment licences in Edinburgh, and the licence was subsequently granted by councillors.
Speaking after the meeting, councillor Arthur said: “It is disappointing that residents were not made aware that the public entertainment licence for this event was coming to committee for approval, as this would have given them a chance to raise concerns with their local councillor.
“Pre-Covid many people had concerns about how the festivals were impacting on the wellbeing of ordinary residents.
“As we come out of the pandemic, it is more important than ever that we find ways of addressing this whilst ensuring the success of the festivals."
A message from the Editor:
Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.
If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.