Calls for Scotland's first female Bishop to be removed after a report claims culture of 'systematic dysfunction' and 'bullying'

The review was commissioned by the SEC College of Bishops following a number of church employees and priests raising concerns of discontent claiming that the Bishop of Aberdeen and Orkney, the Right Rev Anne Dyer, had made their working lives unbearable.

The report by former moderator of the Church of Scotland, Professor Iain Torrance, 72, was due to be published following completion but this action has failed and a petition has now been launched to reveal the findings.

The petition on change.org claims that by refusing to release the report as promised the Episcopalian church has “breached the terms on which participants agreed to offer confidential testimony to the review.”

Almost 500 signatures have been secured arguing that the SEC college of Bishops must “honour their own commitment”.

As reported by The Times the report states that Rev Dyer, 64, who was appointed in 2018 directly by the College of Bishops led by Bishop Mark Strange, should “step back permanently from the diocese.”

Prof Torrance wrote: “I cannot recommend the continuation of a tenure in which I fear that more people will be made to feel diminished and discouraged.

FREE PICTURE: “Last Supper” Ceramic Heads Art at St Mary's Episcopal Cathedral, Edinburgh, 22/08/2021: Cathedral Art Exhibit Represents The Last Supper in Busts of Broken Crockery and Gold: Artist’s beautiful life sized busts of Jesus and the twelve apostles reflects Christian message that the broken can be made whole. Life-sized busts of Jesus and the apostles, created from crockery fragments joined together in gold, are on display on the high altar of Edinburgh’s Episcopalian cathedral in the city's West End. Last Supper, by multi-disciplinary artist Silvy Weatherall (correct), from Irongray, near Dumfries (in Dumfries and Galloway, South West Scotland), is a sculptural interpretation of Leonardo Da Vinci’s iconic painting of the same name. "Last Supper" is at the cathedral until 31 August (2021) and the cathedral is open daily to visitors from 8am to 6pm. More information in accompanying Press Release, or contact PR consultant Matthew Shelley on: 07786 704 299 or [email protected] Photography from: Colin Hattersley Photography - www.colinhattersley.com - [email protected] - 07974 957 388.

“Consequently, I recommend that, for the good of the diocese, she be immediately granted a period of sabbatical leave and step back permanently from the diocese.”

More than 100 people came forward to give evidence and Prof Torrance wrote that a number said they had been bullied by Rev Dyer and almost all of them were “afraid of retaliation in some form or another.”

Within the report Prof Torrance said that Rev Dyer’s position in suspending a respected priest with no explanation was “irrecoverable”, describing the actions as a “scandal”.

One church member who was cited in the report said that they were “stunned by the lack of care and protection offered within the SEC.”

They said: “It seems intent to protect the hierarchy and its own reputation, while people lower down the pecking order are expendable.”

A message from the Editor:Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.