More than 650k of unpaid community service by offenders in Scotland not carried out, figures reveal

More than 650,000 hours of unpaid community service have not been carried out, new figures have revealed.

The statistics were released by the Scottish Conservatives following a series of Freedom of Information (FOI) requests to local authorities in Scotland.

The party has accused SNP and Labour-run councils of letting offenders off the hook as at least 669,838 hours’ worth of unpaid work are yet to be completed as part of community service.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

Read More

Read More
Ukraine-Russia: Russian internet trolls accused of meddling in Scottish independ...
Scottish Conservative MSP Jamie Green. Picture: Pool/Fraser Bremner/Daily Mail

The unfinished work, issued by judges as part of a Community Payback Order (CPO), equates to around 76 years, the Tories have said.

Scottish Conservative justice secretary Jamie Greene hit out at the figures on the sentences, which are issued as an alternative to prison, saying “dangerous criminals” were not facing appropriate consequences for their offences.

According to Criminal Proceedings in Scotland statistics for 2019/20, eight criminals convicted of homicide were given CPOs, along with one person convicted of rape or attempted rape.

And 106 people convicted under the Domestic Abuse Act 2018 were given community service, the statistics show.

Mr Greene said: “This is an absolutely shocking figure that is caused in part by the SNP’s obsession with emptying Scotland’s prisons and dishing out community sentences instead.

“It is bad enough that rapists and domestic abusers are being handed community sentences to begin with, but the fact that the equivalent of 76 years’ worth of unpaid work is outstanding will stun victims of crime.”

The MSP also took aim at some of the activities individuals are assigned on community service. He said the punishments made a “mockery” of the suffering experienced by victims.

The FOI data revealed some of the unpaid work assigned to individuals included making bird tables and building bee hotels.

Mr Greene said: “Making bird tables or bee hotels is not an appropriate punishment for some of the horrific crimes these criminals have committed.

“Scottish Conservative councillors will ensure criminals are made to carry out proper punishments as part of their community sentences.”

The Scottish Conservatives have called for tougher community sentence tasks and are demanding they are always carried out in full.

In 2021, the Scottish Government wrote off 262,153 hours of unpaid work as a result of an “overwhelmed” system caused by the Covid-19 pandemic.


Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.