Comedy review: The Man, Underbelly, Bristo Square - Jersey, Edinburgh

So much is being said about sexual identity at this Fringe that it can start to blur into a miasma of virtue signalling.

The Man, Underbelly, Bristo Square - Jersey (Venue 302)
The Man, Underbelly, Bristo Square - Jersey (Venue 302)

The Man, Underbelly, Bristo Square – Jersey * * * * *

Patrick McPherson takes the character comedy route, via a “workshop”attended by us, the final 100 applicants for the role of The Man.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

On stage we meet Guy, the perfect embodiment of toxic masculinity and proud of it. Guy is a wonderful monster, and McPherson’s performance is ferociously funny, whether explaining dominance to a woman in the front row, or getting slightly sidetracked into the tactics of family Monopoly.

Then there is Emmanuel, about whom there is more than a whiff of lavender and who helps us through the physicality of masculinity. He too is a deliciously awful creature, brought to fabulous life. Yes, the characters are painted with a broad brush, and yes, they are cliches. But within the cartoon outline the fine print of each man-construct onstage (and off) is sharp and telling.

Read More

Read More
All of The Scotsman's 5 star reviews from the Edinburgh Festivals

There is not a speck of fat on any part of the hour – not on the lip-synch extravaganzas, the hilarious game of Dickhead Bingo, the introduction to the six ‘friends’ every man will need, the radio phone-in, or even the spoken word. The show is sculpted like the abs on a comedy Zac Efron.

And that allows for the occasional intense moment – like the section about drunk hugging – that foreshadows the unexpected ending. I am not going to tell you what that is, just that it is brave and passionate and the antithesis of every other Big Finish you will see this month. Be a Man. Go.


Until 26 August