Music review: BBC SSO & Ilan Volkov - The Seven Deadly Sins

Ilan VolkovIlan Volkov
Ilan Volkov
With mention of Brecht and Weill, raunchy 1930s cabaret, and sin in the title, you might have expected something sleazy, if not downright dirty. What conductor Ilan Volkov delivered, however, in his performance of that great duo's 'ballet chanté' The Seven Deadly Sins, with the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, must have been the most squeaky-clean account heard in a while '“ immaculately balanced, tripping along amiably, seldom stormy or suggestive.

BBC SSO/Volkov, Weill: The Seven Deadly Sins ****

City Halls, Glasgow

It meant that Brecht’s bitterly satirical anti-capitalist message – in which sins are subverted to become virtues in an all-consuming quest for profit – came through loud and clear.

But there was also the sense that in being so well-behaved, the performance was – well, missing something.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It’s not an easy piece at the best of times – more agit-prop than opera, and with characters more symbolic than truly human.

And Canadian soprano Measha Brueggergosman, charismatic and full of attitude though she was singing twin sisters Anna I and Anna II, struggled to project over Volkov’s bright, vibrant orchestral sounds with her beautifully rounded, honeyed operatic tone.

A snarl or two might have done the trick – although the all-male quartet from Synergy Vocals fared better as the twins’ despairing family.

But it was a typically enterprising, provocative evening from Volkov nonetheless, and two real discoveries came in the first half, in a pair of exquisitely strange short works by Ferruccio Busoni, Weill’s teacher, balanced precariously between opulence and ominousness, and given astonishingly sensitive, utterly committed performances by Volkov.

They made a fascinatingly languid counterpart to Weill’s acidic musical brittleness, all delivered with admirable care and precision.

Related topics: