Iain Morrison: Scotland impressed in Edmonton but summer tour will only get harder
This morning in Edmonton, Harris was selected at outside centre for his second start for Scotland and he did pretty well. He snaffled one early turnover to win a penalty inside the Canadian twenty-two but then the Newcastle Falcon also lost the ball in contact inside the opposition red zone.
Harris, like the rest of the Scotland team, improved after the break as Scotland ran in five second half tries to go with the two they scored in the first half.
Harris may have improved since February, he almost certainly has, but the truth is that he looked comfortable yesterday because of the opposition; the only similarity between Canada and Wales is the red jerseys that both teams sport.
The Canadian players watched Scotland play so much rugby that they should have paid for tickets at the turnstiles. The red defence had no line speed to speak off. Instead of flying into the face of the Scots, as happened in Cardiff, the Canadians jogged into their face and allowed the Scots to play their game which was a little too lateral. Even then the Scottish back line looked rusty with all five of the second half tries falling to the forwards.
There is plenty to work on. Scotland must get better when receiving restarts, an old bugbear that almost bit them this morning, and they need to improve their overall accuracy which will come.
On the upside Scotland’s scrum was utterly dominant and their driving maul much the same. David Denton looked busy and purposeful with the ball in hand. Ali Price started his rehabilitation after a difficult season and both Jamie Ritchie and Lewis Carmichael looked the part on debut. Oh, and Blair Kinghorn kicks the ball an absolute mile.
In one first half play the fullback hoofed the ball from ten metres inside his own twenty-two and the ball was fielded by his opposite number fifteen metres inside Canada’s twenty-two before he put it off the field on the halfway mark for a easy thirty metre gain for the Scots.
Kinghorn also took the kicks at goal in the second half after Sam Hidalgo-Clyne had been benched despite Adam Hastings coming onto the field early in the second half. Hastings was just one of a host of young Scottish players who looked good in Edmonton but this was Scotland’s easiest game on tour. With the USA and Argentina on the horizon, things will only get harder from here on in although nothing like as hard as European Champions had it.
Australia played Ireland yesterday; a full blooded, brutally physical affair; at times it looked like an entirely different game to the somewhat sedate one that Scotland were involved in. Joe Schmidt was out-smarted on the day, you don’t say that very often, and Ireland were kept try-less but it will have done their younger players like Joey Carbery and Jordan Larmour, a world of good to be experience such Test match intensity.
Ireland remain genuine World Cup contenders while Scotland are still working out how to exit the pool.
While Gregor Townsend will be happy enough with this Canadian result, you can only beat what is put in front of you and Scotland impressed, if only in patches.
However the Scotland coach will have noted with interest one other result from earlier in the weekend; Japan thumped Italy 34-17 in the heat and humidity of Kyushu.
Japan are in Scotland’s pool in next year’s World Cup and the Brave Blossoms’ coach Jamie Joseph will be plotting Scotland’s downfall every waking moment he has.