Fifa moves to calm fears of violence at World Cup

Brazilian police fire rubber bullets and drag a Paranaense fan to safety during the trouble. Picture: Reuters

Fifa condemned the incidents in the southern city of Joinville, where battles between fans halted a decisive Brazilian league match for more than an hour on Sunday and led to the hospitalisation of four people, including one airlifted from the field.

“This is very sad for Brazilian football,” Fifa said in a statement. “Fifa and the local organising committee condemn any form of violence and such incidents should not happen in any football stadium.”

The violence came only two days after Fifa held the draw for the World Cup with an extravagant ceremony in a luxurious resort in north-eastern Brazil.

Hundreds of supporters from Atletico Paranaense and Vasco da Gama charged against each other in Joinville, throwing kicks, punches and using sticks and metal bars in the fighting, forcing the referee to stop the match about 17 minutes into the first half.

Security in Joinville was done by private guards instead of police, similar to what is planned for the World Cup. Only stewards are in charge of fan safety inside stadiums during Fifa events, with authorities usually in charge of security outside the venues.

Sunday’s fighting only stopped after police arrived firing rubber bullets to disperse the crowd.

Fifa said it could not comment on what happened in Joinville because it was not involved in the match, but insisted that it remains confident with security plans for the World Cup.

“For the 2014 Fifa World Cup a very comprehensive security concept is in place in an integrated operation between private and public security authorities to ensure the safety for fans, players and any other stakeholder involved in the event,” the governing body said “The concept has worked very well during the Fifa Confederations Cup and is built on models used at previous Fifa World Cups.”

Most of Fifa’s security concerns ahead of next year’s event have been focused on protests outside of the venues, but the recent violence inside Brazilian stadiums is likely to lead to some apprehension. Even though rival fan groups common to club matches are not expected during World Cup games, it was clear Sunday that the nearly 80 security guards separating the crowd in Joinville were not in position to contain the violence.

Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff said yesterday the sports ministry was accompanying the case and called to an end to lack of punishment in cases of fan violence in Brazil.

“The country of football cannot live with violence in stadiums anymore,” Rousseff said on Twitter. “We need police in the stadiums.”

Newspapers in Brazil showed gruesome images of fans being stepped on, some of them motionless as rival supporters continued to pound them from every side. Some fans who got pulled away from their groups were attacked by up to 20 rivals. A police helicopter had to land on the field of the Arena Joinville to airlift a man with a serious head injury.

Three of the seriously injured men remained hospitalised yesterday, but none of their injuries were life threatening, according to the Hospital Sao Jose. Police said they detained three people on Sunday.

The match, which earned Atletico Paranaense a place in next year’s Copa Libertadores and led to Vasco da Gama’s relegation, was played in Joinville instead of Atletico’s base in Curitiba because the club had already been punished for fan violence earlier this year.

Several other cases of fan violence have hit the World Cup host country in recent months, with champion Cruzeiro, Vasco da Gama, Corinthians and Palmeiras all losing home games because of confrontations inside and outside stadiums. Cruzeiro’s title celebrations a few weeks ago had to be canceled because of fan fighting on the streets of Belo Horizonte.

“We need to do something about this or it will never stop,” Atletico Paranaense defender Luiz Alberto said. “This is a World Cup country. Things need to change.”