Senator censured over ‘disgraceful’ New Zealand killings stance

An Australian senator was censured by his colleagues for seeking to blame the victims of last month’s mosque shootings and vilify Muslims.

Australian senator Fraser Anning sits in the chamber during a session at Parliament House in Canberra. Picture: Mick Tsikas/AAP Image via AP

Senator Fraser Anning was the target of widespread condemnation for blaming the attack in New Zealand on immigration policies.

He faced more criticism later for physically striking a teenager who cracked a raw egg on his head in a viral incident in Melbourne.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Read More

Read More
Christchurch shootings: How the New Zealand mosque attacks unfolded
Teenager Will Connolly breaks an egg on the head of Senator Fraser Anning while he holds a press conference. Picture: AP Photo

On Parliament’s second sitting day since the 15 March attack in which 50 people died, government and opposition lawmakers moved the censure motion against Mr Anning for divisive comments “seeking to attribute blame to victims of a horrific crime and to vilify people on the basis of religion, which do not reflect the opinions of the Australian Senate or the Australian people”.

“Senator Anning’s comments were ugly and divisive, they were dangerous and unacceptable from anyone, let alone a member of this place,” Government Senate Leader Mathias Cormann told the Senate.

Mr Anning dismissed the censure motion as an attack on free speech. “It is also an exercise in left-wing virtue signaling of the worst kind,” he told the Senate before the vote.

He sits as an independent lawmaker after defecting from the anti-Muslim One Nation party, whose two senators abstained from the censure vote.

One Nation Senator Peter Georgiou read a speech on behalf of party leader Pauline Hanson, who was absent.

Ms Hanson said while Mr Anning’s comments were “untimely and therefore deemed highly insensitive, he still maintains a right to his opinion”.

“If One Nation endorses your action to censure Senator Anning, your freedom of speech as elected members of this chamber will be removed,” the speech said.

A day after the Christchurch attacks, Mr Anning faced more criticism for physically striking the teenager who cracked an egg on his head at a Melbourne public appearance - 17-year-old Will Connolly, who became known around the world as “Egg Boy”.

Mr Anning today criticised Prime Minister Scott Morrison for saying at the time the Senator should “be subject to the full force of the law” for his retaliation against Mr Connolly. Police investigated the altercation, but no charges have been announced.

“It might have only been an idiot with an egg this time, but there is a continuum that begins with this and ends with a fanatic with a gun or a bomb,” Mr Anning said.

He added: “But apparently, according to Prime Minister Morrison, that’s OK, as long as the victims are conservatives.”

The minor Greens party later failed to win majority support for a motion for the Senate to suspend Mr Anning.

Mehreen Faruqi, a Pakistan-born Greens senator, produced an online petition to the Senate with more than 1.4 million signatures calling for Mr Anning to resign.

She argued he should be suspended as well as censured.

“It is terrifying that rightwing extremist groups have a found a mouthpiece in Federal Parliament,” Ms Faruqi told the Senate.

An Irish-born lawmaker who criticized British policy toward his homeland in 1920 became the only Australian legislator to be expelled from Parliament by a vote of colleagues.

Senate president Scott Ryan warned that laws had been tightened in the 1980s so that suspending Anning could be challenged in the courts.

After New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern previously called Anning’s comments on the shootings “a disgrace,” her deputy Winston Peters on Tuesday called Mr Anning a “jingoistic moron.”

Mr Anning came under blistering criticism over tweets within hours of the massacre, including one that said, “Does anyone still dispute the link between Muslim immigration and violence?”

“The real cause of the bloodshed on New Zealand streets today is the immigration program which allowed Muslim fanatics to migrate to New Zealand in the first place,” he said in a later statement.

Australian white supremacist Brenton Tarrant has been charged with murder in the shootings and is due to appear in a New Zealand court on Friday.