CalMac’s hugely over budget ferries Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa may never run on low emission fuels
Cost of LNG fuel and storage tanks could mean vessels use only diesel
CalMac’s two hugely late and over budget dual fuel ferries may never again run on the low-emission natural gas for which they were designed, MSPs were told on Wednesday.
The operator’s chief executive told Holyrood’s transport committee that a question mark hung over using liquefied natural gas (LNG) rather than diesel because of the cost of the fuel and building port storage tanks.
.jpeg?trim=0,0,0,0&width=640&quality=65)

Committee convener Willie Rennie described the situation as the “ultimate farce”.
LNG was transported 500 miles by tanker from Kent to power Glen Sannox, the first of the two ferries, when it entered service last year - six years late - because of the lack of supplies in Scotland.
It had been envisaged when the ferry and sister vessel Glen Rosa were planned about 15 years ago that LNG would become available, but that didn’t happen.
Glen Sannox initially operated between Troon and Brodick in Arran but was redeployed to the Western Isles in the summer, which has no access to LNG.
Glen Rosa is due to serve the Arran route next spring if it is completed by its latest deadline of February, more than eight-and-a-half years late. Both ferries are four times over budget.
CalMac chief executive Duncan Mackison told the committee: “There is a question mark [over whether it will used by the ferries].
“It will hinge on the investment case to put LNG facilities to where that vessel will run from.”
Mr Mackison also agreed that if the price was too high, CalMac would not to use it.
Kevin Hobbs, chief executive of Scottish Government ferry-owning firm Caledonian Maritime Assets, said LNG had been seen as the “fuel for the future” but its price had “escalated beyond anything anybody could ever have imagined” and it was now “hugely expensive”.
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn told the committee: “The determination that we will need to make is whether the economics in relation to LNG to deliver for the public both in terms of expenditure but also in terms of their reliability of services to the islands.”
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.