Scotland's islands are pitted against each other in a new table - but do you agree with the scores?
Not much stands between the islands’ scores but do you agree with the ratings?
Consumer watchdog Which? has applied its tried and tested ratings to Scotland’s islands.
From Orkney to Benbecula, 15 of the 700 Scottish isles have been scored on their hotel prices, beaches and ‘peace and quiet’ - based on over 1,000 visitor experiences.
Not much stands between the islands under the spotlight but do homegrown critics agree with the ratings?
Top of the Which? chart, with an overall destination rating of 90 per cent, is Orkney - given five stars for tourist attractions and ‘peace and quiet’ but only three for food and drink.
Orkney - which is made up of around 70 islands - is home to the most incredible Neolithic landscape in the world.
Which? said: “This includes the remarkable village of Skara Brae (which predates the pyramids), the Ring of Brodgar, the Standing Stones of Stenness, and the chambered tomb of Maeshowe – which together make up one mind-boggling Unesco World Heritage Site, so rich in meaning you’ll be won over by its mystical atmosphere.”
Barra - with the only beach runway for chartered flights in the world - and Shetland - not so much an island as an entire archipelago - take joint second place on the table with overall scores of 86 per cent. They might be 500 miles apart but they come together to share five star ratings for beaches, scenery and ‘peace and quiet’ and both were given only two stars for food and drink.
Arran - one of the easiest Scottish islands to reach - was ranked third place with an overall score of 85 per cent. The island scored five stars in the scenery category only but beaches, accommodation, ‘peace and quiet’ and value for money were all rated four star.
Next on chart is Harris which was deemed the most expensive island to stay on with an average hotel price of £222. It’s Caribbeanesque beaches and “rugged” and “absolutely stunning” scenery were singled out by visitors. It is therefore no surprise that Harris was given five stars for scenery and peace and quiet earning an overall destination score of 83 per cent.
In the middle of the table, Iona was given a score of 80 per cent but there wasn’t deemed to be enough visitor data for beaches, food and drink, accommodation or value for money to give it a score between one and five stars.
The bottom three islands on the chart are Skye, Bute and Benbecula with overall scores of 75, 74 and 72 per cent, respectively.
Skye earned top marks for scenery but an average hotel price of £204 put value for money at three stars. Comparatively the average price of a nights stay in Bute is just £85 but food and drink, accommodation and tourist attractions only fetched two stars.
There wasn’t enough data to score Bebecula’s accommodation but beaches and ‘peace and quiet’ are five star.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)
Lismore didn’t make the table but it is cited as the Expert’s Pick which adds: “The quiet, unassuming isle of Lismore, separated from Scotland’s west coast by Loch Linnhe, is a great introduction to island life, especially for those short of time.
“It’s just a five-minute ferry journey from Port Appin, and once here, you can bask in the natural beauty of it all...it ticks a lot of boxes for Scotland fans.”
Scoring aside, Which? recognises there is “little to separate the islands” and urges all would-be Scottish Island hoppers to “take your pick”.
The ratings are based on an online survey conducted in November 2025 with 627 members of the Which? Connect panel who shared 1,115 experiences of visiting one or more Scottish island in the previous two years.
Destination score is based on a visitors’ satisfaction with the island and the likelihood they would recommend it.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.