Rod Grant: Wealth is no longer a central issue for an independent education

THE subject of independent education is often met with a vitriolic reaction where individuals denigrate the system as being plagued by elitism, inequality and restricted access. The debate is particularly vicious in Scotland where political persuasion often influences personal views regarding equality within society.

I feel I can speak with a little authority on this matter, as I was educated in both sectors and have taught in both sectors. The idea that private schools are populated only by the children of the wealthy is an absolute myth. In many families (my own included) both parents work full-time and go without in order to meet the fees. Furthermore, financial assistance is now available and is often based entirely on financial need.

Regardless of income, the sector has become more accessible than it has ever been, with some schools offering free places for those with the most limited of financial means. What this means in practice is that "private" schools contain a healthy mix of parents from a wide range of social and cultural backgrounds.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

For some parents, the best education on offer will mean a maintained school in their local community; for others, it will mean an independent school, chosen for a huge variety of reasons often not linked to the notion of academic excellence.

I, for one, am not interested in whether my school community is made up of wealthy individuals or intelligent children. What I am interested in is having parents who are seeking the best for their children, who are committed to the values of a traditional Scottish education and who make an informed choice about the quality of my school and what it has to offer.

The cynical among us will point to the law on charitable status as being directly responsible for the independent sector opening its doors that little bit wider but, whatever the motive, that is now immaterial. The fact is that if you wish your child to be independently educated, the ability to pay is no longer the central issue and regardless of your political persuasion, this should be welcomed.

• Rod Grant of Clifton Hall School near Edinburgh