SNP must win majority for right to hold indyref2 says senior Scottish Tory

The SNP will have to win a majority at the next Holyrood election in order for a second independence referendum to take place, a senior Scottish Conservative figure has said.

It comes as Stephen Kerr, the party’s chief whip in the Scottish Parliament, said it was time to unite behind the Prime Minister despite the Partygate scandal.

The Central Scotland MSP, who was standing in for the ill Douglas Ross, said the Scottish Conservative leader’s decision to u-turn on his call for Boris Johnson to resign was a personal one.

Hide Ad

His comments come as a new poll showed that two-thirds of Scots think that the Prime Minister should resign due to Partygate, alongside a boost for unionists with a 52/48 lead for No.

Scottish Conservative MSP Stephen Kerr was speaking to The Scotsman in Aberdeen.
Hide Ad

Mr Kerr was asked to explain why there was a different bar for the SNP/Green coalition in Holyrood versus the Liberal Democrat/Conservative coalition in Westminster in terms of having a democratic mandate.

Read More
Scottish independence referendum discussions should stop due to Ukraine, say maj...
Hide Ad

He said: “There isn’t necessarily a different bar but it has to be realised that issues relating to the constitution are reserved and therefore it isn’t a straightforward matter.

"Our position remains that the SNP tested their manifesto commitment for a second independence referendum and they didn’t win a majority.

Hide Ad

"All of the subsequent polling has shown, as highlighted by today’s poll in The Scotsman, that there is no appetite for this.

"It’s just not the will of the Scottish people.”

Hide Ad

Asked if a majority in a future Holyrood election would be the point at which the Conservative party would agree there was a democratic mandate for indyref2, Mr Kerr said the “practical route” was a Section 30 order being approved by the UK Government.

When it was put to him that this was impossible due to the fact the SNP could never win a majority in Westminster, Mr Kerr added: “The SNP would need to get a majority in the Scottish Parliament as far as I am concerned.

Hide Ad

"That would need to become the basis on which any future discussion we have, but I think Alister Jack has been quite clear in many respects about this issue as well.”

Mr Jack has previously said that 60 per cent of Scots would need to back a referendum in order for the UK Government to allow a referendum.

Hide Ad

Mr Kerr also defended his party leader’s decision to withdraw his letter of no confidence in the Prime Minister and that he was given a “little prior warning” about the move.

However, he said the Scottish Conservative group, of which 27 of 31 MSPs backed Mr Ross in his calls for Mr Johnson to resign, was told “not as quickly as I would have liked them to be told”.

Hide Ad

Asked whether he believed the Prime Minister was still fit for office, Mr Kerr refused to answer and said: "We’ll come back to all of that stuff, we’ve got to get through this global crisis.

"What this global crisis does is it gives us perspective.

Hide Ad

"Right now what is important is that we unite...and that we support the Prime Minister and we support the government because actually the Prime Minister and the government have been doing all the right things.”

However, the SNP accused Mr Kerr of “shifting the goalposts”, labelling the comments worthy of a “democratic outrage”.

Hide Ad

A spokesperson said: “In any other democracy - where the electoral system was designed expressly to prevent parliamentary majorities - this would be called out as a democratic outrage.

“But not in Scotland, Stephen Kerr and other leading Tories disrespect the all-party agreement in the 2014 Smith Commission with ridiculous shifting of the goalposts when they lose election after election, and then try to present it as a reasonable position.

Hide Ad

“In May’s election the people of Scotland returned a majority of MSPs in favour of a referendum – greater than the one in 2011.

“If the Tories don’t like that, instead of undermining democracy, they should focus on how they can win an election in Scotland - something they’ve failed to do in Scotland for nearly 70 years."

Hide Ad

Want to hear more from The Scotsman's politics team? Check out the latest episode of our political podcast, The Steamie.

It's available wherever you get your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Hide Ad

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

Hide Ad

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.