Scots ‘punished’ for working while on Universal Credit

Holyrood's social security committee fears scheme could result in Scots being 'punished' for working. Picture: PA
Holyrood's social security committee fears scheme could result in Scots being 'punished' for working. Picture: PA
Share this article
Have your say

A pilot scheme to move benefits claimants onto Universal Credit (UC) should be urgently stopped until there is more clarity around the impact it will have on those affected, MSPs have warned.

Holyrood’s social security committee fears it could result in Scots being “punished” for working. Concerns have already been raised around the implementation of the new benefits by the committee, which has previously urged the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to halt its rollout.

However, in March work and pensions secretary Amber Rudd confirmed that claimants in Harrogate who still receive the old-style benefits will be the first people to be moved to UC under a pilot scheme starting this month.

Committee convener SNP MSP Bob Doris warned the scheme had been “littered with mistakes” since being introduced in 2013. He said the pilot scheme should be stopped, adding: “We are deeply concerned that despite raising this issue as part of the committee’s In-Work Poverty Inquiry with the DWP in January and the UK Government’s failure to appear at our committee to give evidence, they have carried on with plans for implementation regardless.

“This movement represents a huge cultural shift and we do not believe it is right to sanction the working poor, effectively punishing people for going to their work.

“The DWP has said they are currently taking a ‘light touch’ approach to in-work conditionality or sanctions, but there is little confidence that when the system rolls out more widely that low paid and part-time workers won’t suffer as a result.

“The rollout of Universal Credit has been littered with mistakes and it is vital that this latest pilot is put on hold to ensure that there is no negative impact upon claimants who rely on this money.”

The committee has also stated it is opposed in principle to attaching punitive conditions to those already in work.

Speaking at the time of the announcement of the pilot in March, Ms Rudd said: “Moving people from the old and outdated benefits system to Universal Credit is a positive and important moment.

“Once on Universal Credit, people will benefit from a more personal service and can expect to receive up to six benefits combined into one, making it easier for them to manage their money.”