SNP rules out independent police gross misconduct hearings for officers despite ‘two-tier’ warning

Police in Scotlandplaceholder image
Police in Scotland

The Scottish Police Federation have called for all officers facing gross misconduct allegations to have a panel with an independent chair.

SNP ministers have ruled out allowing police officers to undergo gross misconduct panels led by independent chairs - arguing the move would be too costly and not “proportionate”.

The intervention from SNP Justice Secretary, Neil Gray, comes after calls from the Scottish Police Federation and the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents for gross misconduct hearings for rank and file officers to be independently chaired amid concerns over a “two-tier” system with senior officers.

Regulations are being updated over police musconuct processesplaceholder image
Regulations are being updated over police musconuct processes

Regulations to update police misconduct processes , which would allow legally-qualified chairs to oversee gross misconduct cases for senior officers, will be considered by MSPs. Extending independent chairs for officers below senior rank would likely require new primary legislation to be drawn up.

According to the most recent annual report by the Scottish Police Authority (SPA), 34 gross misconduct hearings took place in 2024-25, with eight officers dismissed - up from 18 hearings the previous year. A significant number of hearings do not proceed as a result of officers taking early retirement or resigning.

In the first quarter of 2026-27, covering April - June 2026, nine officers were scheduled to attend a gross misconduct hearing with four resigning in advance of their hearing.

David Kennedy, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, which represents rank and file officers, said that allowing an independent process for all officers for gross misconduct hearings “would be a very good and fair approach that our members would accept”.

David Kennedy of the Scottish Police Federationplaceholder image
David Kennedy of the Scottish Police Federation | PA

He added: “We want proceedings to be independently chaired. There is no training for superintendents or chief superintendents who chair misconduct or gross misconduct hearings—or not the training that you would expect that they would want to ensure that they were capable of doing what they have to do.

“I know that a lot of good superintendents and chief superintendents chair the hearings, but we must look at fairness and accountability. Having independent chairs is the only thing that would be seen as fair by our members and by the public. To be honest, it is the fairest way to operate, and we will always have unfairness if we do not do that.

“Even if a gross misconduct case against an officer is found to be not proven, the public could say that that happened because it was decided in house.”

Chief superintendent Rob Hay from the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents, warned about a risk of “a two-tier experience of misconduct”.

He added that there is a “public interest associated with ensuring that hearing chairs are demonstrably impartial”.

But in a letter to Holyrood’s justice committee, Mr Gray has ruled out the move, arguing that “the principle that responsibility for standards and responsibility for disciplinary outcomes should remain aligned”.

“If the Chief Constable is accountable for standards within policing, it is appropriate that the Chief Constable retains meaningful responsibility for enforcing those standards”, the Justice Secretary added.

Justice Secretary Neil Grayplaceholder image
Justice Secretary Neil Gray

Mr Gray said: “Recent reporting to the Scottish Police Authority's Complaints and Conduct Committee demonstrates that the conduct system deals with a significant volume of cases each year.

“A model based on independently chaired panels for all gross misconduct proceedings - 424 initial assessments in 2025 - would require substantial additional financial, administrative and legal resources and, in practice, a significantly expanded role for an independent body such as the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner in supporting and administering proceedings.

“The Scottish government does not consider that such an approach would be proportionate or assist the timely resolution of cases. It would potentially include three different legally qualified people, appointed by the Lord President to complete preliminary assessment, conduct the hearing and hear any appeal.”

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice