Three senior managers suspended from troubled Historic Environment Scotland in shock to staff
David Mitchell was a long term HES employee and well-respected within the organisation and his sudden departure has shocked staff.
Three senior staff members - including a director - have been suspended from a troubled heritage quango.
In what is the latest scandal for Historic Environment Scotland (HES), workers have been told the trio are “currently out of the business”.
David Mitchell, Director of Cultural Assets; Colin Tennant, Head of Technical Conservation; and Graham Briggs, Project Manager, have all stepped back from the organisation “with immediate effect”.
It is understood the three men were suspended from work on Friday last week.
In an email to staff, interim CEO of the organisation Stephen Uphill, confirmed the three men had left HES.
He went on to ask staff not to brief the media or speculate on the situation.
Mr Uphill’s correspondence reads: “Yesterday, I informed senior leaders across the organisation, as well as those colleagues most directly affected within Cultural Assets. I had intended to provide a brief update to all colleagues on Friday.
“However, in light of media coverage this morning, I felt it was important that all colleagues heard directly from me today.
“While I appreciate colleagues may have questions, given the sensitive and confidential nature of the situation, we are unable to provide any further information.”
Mr Uphill went on to tell staff that they must “allow established processes to take place appropriately”.
David Martin, the former head of Dundee City Council, was brought in to prepare a culture review of HES after a string of high profile scandals.
One insider said: "We were promised a revolution in David Martin's culture review but there has been no real change as Audit Scotland made clear last week.
“We deserve better but the currently leadership has failed time and time again.
"There is no doubting the serious nature of today's announcement but there is clearly more to come.
“This isn't the first time we have heard people are "out of the business" before more revelations hit the headlines.”
Dr Mitchell was a long term HES employee and well-respected within the organisation.
One of its longest-serving members of staff, he joined Historic Environment Scotland's predecessor organisation in 2002.
He became Director of Conservation in 2008, and subsequently held the position of Director of Cultural Assets.
Dr Mitchell was also in charge of the Archive House project, which faced criticism in the Auditor General’s report into HES.
Auditors found that the HES board was not provided with a paper to scrutinise the cancellation of a specialist archive storage project, which has already cost £2.9 million, with a further £0.5 million likely to be spent.
One of the Auditor’s recommendations was a conflict of interests register of interests for senior staff.
Following enquiries by The Scotsman, HES said the register has been completed but is not yet public.
The three suspensions are the latest in a string of high profile staffing issues at the quango.
Sir Mark Jones resigned as chairman in July 2026 after just nine months in the post.
He was replaced by Ronnie Hinds, the former chief executive of Fife Council, on an interim basis.
Sir Mark had replaced Hugh Hall, who left the organisation as the Scottish Government announced an investigation into his conduct.
Katerina Brown, chief executive, also left in September, less than two years after taking up the position.
Craig Mearns, director of operations, also left earlier this year after allegations of racist comments about visitors to Edinburgh Castle.
The allegations against him had been upheld following an internal process.
Another senior manager, whose behaviour at an Edinburgh Castle corporate event attracted national attention after she was accused of twerking in front of actor Martin Compston, left in June. She had also faced allegations of sexual harassment from a junior male colleague.
Stephen Duncan, director of marketing and engagement, announced in September that he would leave after 17 years with the organisation.
He had been suspended for almost a year amid investigations into procurement concerns and questions surrounding hospitality expenditure.
A spokesperson for Historic Environment Scotland said: “We can confirm that three members of staff are currently out of the business. For confidentiality reasons, we are unable to comment further on individual personnel matters, including the circumstances involved. We would caution against speculation about the reasons for this. HES is following its established policies and procedures, and appropriate interim arrangements are in place to ensure continuity across the organisation.”
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.
