Former SNP minister raises concerns over moves to make Covid powers permanent

A former SNP minister has raised concerns over plans to make some emergency coronavirus powers permanent.

Alex Neil, who served under both former first minister Alex Salmond and his successor Nicola Sturgeon, spoke out following criticism from opposition parties.

Labour warned the proposals would allow the Scottish Government to "shut down schools and confine people to their homes at the drop of a hat".

Hide Ad
Read More
FMQs: Nicola Sturgeon urged to take action over Scotland’s social care crisis
Concerns have been raised over plans to make some emergency Covid powers permanent
Hide Ad

The Coronavirus (Recovery and Reform) (Scotland) Bill would give ministers the ability to respond to public health emergencies in a similar way to legislation passed in the wake of Covid.

This includes imposing lockdown restrictions, allowing court hearings to take place remotely and restricting access to schools.

Hide Ad

The Government said the move would maintain provisions that enable ministers “to enact measures via public health regulations for any future public health threats, bringing Scotland into line with England and Wales”.

But both Labour and the Tories have branded it a "power grab".

Hide Ad

Writing on Twitter, Mr Neil said he agreed "no government should get such draconian powers other than in very exceptional circumstances and only with explicit parliamentary approval".

Mr Neil was health secretary from 2012 to 2014 and social justice, communities and pensioners' rights secretary from 2014 to 2016.

Hide Ad

Murdo Fraser, Scottish Conservative spokesman for Covid recovery, said: “The SNP’s plans to retain Covid powers are facing condemnation across the political divide – and Alex Neil is right to stand up to his party over this blatant power grab.

“Such extensive powers should only ever be granted temporarily, in emergency circumstances.

Hide Ad

“Anyone who wants a fair, accountable and democratic government should be appalled by these proposals, regardless of their political position.

“If the SNP won’t listen to the 85 per cent of Scots who are opposed to these powers, they should heed the words of their own political grandee, and row back on this unacceptable overreach.”

Hide Ad

Deputy First Minister John Swinney previously said the Scottish Government had "already removed many of the temporary measures that supported our response to the pandemic, which are no longer needed".

He said: “However, we believe those pragmatic reforms that have delivered demonstrable benefit to the people of Scotland should continue."



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.