Alex Salmond asked top lawyer about pardoning William Wallace


Lord Frank Mulholland, who was Lord Advocate between 2011 and 2016, said he was unsure if the former first minister was being serious and that the “humorous” conversation did not lead to any action.
Alex Salmond asked Scotland’s former top law officer if he could pardon William Wallace.
Lord Frank Mulholland, who was Lord Advocate between 2011 and 2016, said he was unsure if the former first minister was being serious and that the “humorous” conversation did not lead to any action.
Lord Mulholland was speaking at the House of Commons Scottish Affairs Committee’s investigation of the dual role of the Lord Advocate. The job leads Scotland’s prosecution service but also sits in the Scottish cabinet.
It comes after previous Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain sent minutes to First Minister John Swinney briefing him on confidential details of former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell’s case before they became public.
When asked about political interference, Lord Mulholland told MPs: "I'll tell you a funny story, but it's a true story.
"Alex Salmond once asked me - I don't know if he was serious or not - but he once asked me to look into a pardon quashing the conviction of William Wallace.
"I remember the conversation because it was quite a humorous conversation. And my answer was, 'well I'm afraid you're speaking to the wrong Lord Advocate, because I think he was tried and convicted in England so you'll have to make that request to the Criminal Cases Review Committee down south'."
Conservative MP Douglas Lumsden then said: "I hope that wasn't a serious request from Alex Salmond, because I guess that could be seen as political interference?"
Lord Mulholland added: "I don't think it was but it was funny at the time. And when I came back with the story, everyone was laughing."
William Wallace was tried and convicted of treason at Westminster Hall, and was hung, drawn and quartered in 1305.
The Scottish Affairs Committee is also holding an inquiry into the funding of political parties. It is inspired by the conviction of Mr Murrell, who is former FM Nicola Sturgeon’s estranged husband.
Dorothy Bain, who served as Lord Advocate between 2021 and 2026, attracted controversy when she briefed the FM about the sum of money Mr Murrell was accused of embezzling from the SNP and an estimate of when it would come to court.
She said it was longstanding practice for minister be updated on high-profile cases, in part to avoid them being prejudiced by public statements.
But she has been accused of political interference from opposition parties.
Lord Mulholland refused to comment on Mr Murrell’s case.
But he said he had never briefed a politician on the evidence in any investigation and hadn’t attempted any political interference when he was Lord Advocate.
He argued against splitting the the dual role, saying it was helpful for creating policy and advising the Scottish Government on high-profile cases.
He also told MPs that he briefed Mr Salmond on the decision to apply for World’s End murderer Angus Sinclair’s acquittal to be overturned - but that this was “shortly before” it was made public.
When asked by committee chair Patricia Ferguson if he would brief ministers on a case involving an MSP, where there is a legal convention that law officers recuse themselves from decision making, he said: "I don't think I would, to be honest… I can't swear to it, but the way I would think, I can't imagine me doing that."
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.