It is frankly insulting of David Cameron to expect Scots to surrender independence in return for some unspecified extensions of devolution; as Wilson reminds us, this promise was made after the 1979 referendum, yet five further Tory governments since then have delivered none.
Any such “rewards” would be unlikely to be arranged before the general election, and would therefore depend on: 1) a Tory government returned with overall majority and 2) Cameron remaining as prime minister. Both are doubtful.
As Andrew Wilson indicates, even the Scottish Parliament was given no more powers than those of the Scottish secretary, plus the unusable tax-varying facility – and we still have that secretary at Westminster. Now there’s an obvious gesture for the PM to make: establish that post in the Scottish Parliament where it belongs, then we might lose the feeling of being regarded as some colonial outpost.
Robert Dow, Tranent