Scotland on Sunday readers' letters: Did COP26 deliver more than just blah, blah, blah?

COP26 in Glasgow promised much but did it deliver? Once again political leaders from around the world met in an attempt to agree measures to reduce climate change.

The Global Day of Action for Climate Justice march during the COP26 conference in Glasgow. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)
The Global Day of Action for Climate Justice march during the COP26 conference in Glasgow. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)

The conference provided an opportunity for change but whilst leaders flew in and flew back again, there appears little resolve to make the sacrifices needed to change the current path we are on.

Whilst many nations drown both in debt and in rising sea levels, the rich nations of the world were either absent or sleeping at conference through ignorance and apathy of the plight of the worlds poorest and most vulnerable countries. Many people may be asking what hope is there, if our leaders cannot see, hear, nor speak for a world crying out for solidarity and recognition of the precipice we stand upon. So is there hope of better days ahead? Who will stand up for those least able to protect themselves and what can we do about it?

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

I believe strongly that there is hope and indeed inspiration, not in our world leaders, but in the very people that marched together in Glasgow to represent the peoples of the world who were not able to be in Glasgow. Everyday anonymous heroes are campaigning in villages, communities and isolated wildernesses throughout the world, seeking to create a more sustainable planet that shares its resources for the better good of all. I heard these stories time and time again on the streets of Glasgow meeting people from around the world that had come to Glasgow, not as world leaders, but as activists and ordinary citizens who recognise that for Climate Change to happen, we as individuals and communities need to change too.

During COP26 events and conferences took place in Glasgow to discuss how we might influence change internationally to address the reality of our nations failure to share in our resources sustainably and reduce the impact of rising temperatures. In recognition of the impact of plastics on the planet, Dovesdale Action Group (also representing anti-incineration groups across the UK; UKWIN) was invited to join representatives from Belgium, Ghana, USA, Spain and Chile to discuss the consequences of our actions globally and what we can do as individuals and communities to encourage change locally and nationally. The invitation to speak at COP26 was both humbling and daunting at the same time but the experience was rewarding in recognising we are not alone in our endeavours to protect our communities.

Presently South Lanarkshire is awaiting an application from Viridor to build the largest waste incinerator in Scotland. Dovesdale Action Group took the decision to seek a moratorium nationally on incineration to protect not just our communities but all the towns and villages across Scotland facing the massive impact of millions of tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions into our atmosphere. To this end we have sought the support of organisations and politicians who share our concerns and we have been successful in achieving a Review of Incineration in Scotland as announced by the Scottish Government recently. We believe the evidence of Climate Change through the emission of greenhouse gases is overwhelming. Equally, we believe the impact on public health and the rural economy through such emissions will be detrimental to the national interests and the improvement of recycling targets and better packaging. Incineration is neither clean nor green and has no place in what is known as the ‘circular economy’. In short, multi-national companies should not be profiting from pollution and greenwashing the impacts of Climate Change.

Climate Change knows no borders, so it is essential we unite not just in Scotland but internationally to stop the increasing number of incinerators being erected across the world polluting our soil, water and air, and stop the burning of recyclable materials that could otherwise be reused as a resource. We hope in the months ahead the political parties of Scotland will unite to establish a new path by leading other nations to create a more sustainable waste industry by planting the seeds of change by targeting an end to incineration. We believe that time for change is now.

COP26 has come to an end and the time for talking is over. As Greta Thunberg suggested, we will be judged not by our words, but by our actions. With our young people leading the way, Dovesdale Action Group hope others will be inspired and invigorated to join the movement to influence policy change nationally and indeed locally in how we face the challenges of Climate Change. How many COP events do we need until it’s too late? The clock is ticking…

John Young, Dovesdale Action Group

Cambo outsourced

Last week Nicola Sturgeon was outsourcing the decision on the Cambo oilfield to Boris Johnson and a Rigorous Climate Assessment, a kind of rerun of the "five tests" Gordon Brown defined to inform a decision on joining the Euro. Except that Ms Sturgeon never defined the terms of such a test or what would constitute a pass or fail.

No wonder, since that would lay the ground rules for how long she could sit on the fence, so what seems to have happened is she decided to just announce that she was against it, and lo and behold it turned out that the Labour party, formerly the champions of workers and industry, in the shape of Monica Lennon MSP, fed the neccessary question at FMQs.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

So, no matter the outcome, Sturgeon wants Cambo stopped. No matter if we import the gas we need for the Grangemouth petrochemicals industry at higher financial and climate cost, no matter if potential investors in the North Sea are already having second thoughts, no matter thousand of jobs are at risk, and, amazingly, no matter she has obliterated 40 years of "it's Scotland's oil", the foundation of the Scexit case.

Allan Sutherland, Stonehaven

Read More
COP26: Nicola Sturgeon says Cambo oil field should 'not get the green light' as ...

Good cop, bad cop

Nicola seems to have had a fine COP26, being constantly in the media, on a matter that belongs to Westminster. At the same time, as Anas Sarwar pointed out, people are dying due to ambulance delays. You kind of get the feeling that Nicola fiddles whilst Rome burns - what about the day job!

William Ballantine, Bo'ness

Write to Scotland on Sunday

We welcome your thoughts. Write to [email protected] including name, address and phone number – we won't print full details. Keep letters under 300 words, with no attachments, and avoid 'Letters to the Editor' or similar in your subject line.



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.