Readers' Letters: McAllan should read report on Neets before dismissing it
Education Secretary should hang fire on gloom over Milburn Review, says reader
Most of us are really guessing what might be in the Milburn Review investigating why over one million young people aged 16-24 in the UK are not in education, employment, or training (Neets) which, as I write – 16 November – is yet to be published. That has not stopped Mairi McAllan, our Education Secretary, predicting gloom from its recommendations (your report, 16 November).
One thing that is certain about the Review is that it has been researched, led by an experienced politician. This is in stark contrast to the “back of a fag packet” recommendations from her SNP pals concerning cutting health boards, price controlling basic foods, state control of buses and many other ludicrous ideas that never actually see the light of day.
Surely it would be better to wait, read the report, assess its impact on the future prospects for our youth and then look for how it might bring benefit? Then, if proper assessment suggests better alternatives, Ms McAllan might make counter-constructive recommendations so that we can have some confidence that our youth are not simply going to be brushed aside in favour of the SNP protecting its budget?


Of course, she may have the usual secret SNP plan based on independence, and membership of the EU, being the answer to everything.
Ken Currie, Edinburgh
Why the secrecy?
It has been revealed via a Freedom Of Information (FOI) request that the UK government has done extensive polling on Scottish independence using public money but is refusing to publish the results. Why? It is obvious that they know, as we in Scotland know, that there is a majority for independence!
Furthermore, with Prime Minister Andy Burnham talking about “transparency in government”, the spending of taxpayers’ money on the secret polling means that through FOI rules the taxpayer has the right to know the results.
However, with Tory threats that they may rescind Holyrood completely, the people of Scotland should be alarmed.
When England dragged the UK out of the EU, Scotland was promised more devolved powers to devo-max or even a federal system – none of which transpired.
Grant Frazer, Newtonmore, Highland
Clip quango wings
Well done The Scotsman for zeroing in on the story of a secretive funding cabal and £2 billion of taxpayers’ money.
I read with absolute democratic delight The Scotsman editorial about the Scottish Funding Council (SFC) and the fact its “Refusal to identify four colleges at risk of insolvency underlines the lack of democratic accountability of quangos” (14 November).
There were ten words in particular which should be taken as a poetic prescription to positively enhance the health of our democracy: “The outsourcing of government functions to quangos must be reversed”.
If Scotland were to swallow such a prescription she could be healed of the costly and destructive quango-itis so devastating to our democracy.
(Dr) Steven William Welsh, Stornoway, Western Isles
Nonsense
I have to take issue with Stan Grodynski’s claim (Letters, 16 November) on Barnett consequentials and the impact on them as a result of NHS England’s spend on private contractors.
His assertions are nothing short of blatant nationalist propaganda nonsense!
Barnett consequentials are based on total expenditure on public services in England, so it is of absolutely no consequence what promotion of said expenditure is with the private sector! Healthcare, as we are all aware, is a totally devolved matter, therefore Scotland is free to make its own decisions on whether to involve the private sector or not.
He also throws in, for good measure, one of the favourite nationalist falsehoods that Scotland “gets back” far less from Westminster than it contributes into the Treasury by way of taxes.
The Scottish government is responsible for producing the GERS figures, so why would they totally misrepresent the income from Scottish taxes in these figures, and these figures prove that the nationalists’ claims in this regard are also nonsense! GDP does not represent government income.
Michael Officer, Bridge of Earn, Perth and Kinross
Stick to guns
Apparently up to 100 Labour MPs have signed or will sign a letter opposing the Rosebank oilfield. This caucus of “luxury belief” MPs, with their stances on net zero, benefits, immigration, Palestine, DEI, EU and defence will destroy Andy Burnham’s premiership and government unless – fortified by his overwhelming 158 Commons majority – he cracks down by ignoring them, removing the whip, threatening an election and inviting them to join the Green Party where they belong.
Otherwise the whole UK state will be at risk, not least because it will be the proof the SNP need to argue – and convince many – that things can only get better in an independent Scotland – ironically, because they are promising these suicidal policies in stilts.
People need, will respect, vote for – a leader who speaks out and sticks to his or her guns on what needs to be done. You have a huge majority, Andy. Use it or lose it.
Allan Sutherland, Stonehaven, Aberdeenshire
History repeats
The world should recognise that Vladimir Putin's attempt to subjugate and destroy Ukraine is not the first time a Russian autocrat has sought to extinguish Ukrainian independence and identity.
In 1932-33, Joseph Stalin presided over the Holodomor, a man-made famine which killed millions of Ukrainians. When collectivisation and disastrous agricultural policies had brought about a catastrophic food shortage, Stalin did not come to the rescue. Instead, he continued to requisition Ukraine's grain, confiscated food from starving households and prevented peasants from escaping in search of food. Millions died while grain was taken away from the very people who had grown it.
But Stalin’s cruelty was accompanied by another weapon: deception. He understood the value of sympathetic Western opinion and the usefulness of influential visitors prepared to believe what they were shown. Among those who praised or defended aspects of the Soviet experiment were George Bernard Shaw, Sidney and Beatrice Webb and the American journalist Walter Duranty. HG Wells, who interviewed Stalin in 1934, also helped give the Soviet leader an audience among Western intellectuals.
Carefully organised visits presented model farms, prosperous communities and apparently contented workers. Such displays concealed the reality of collectivisation, repression and starvation. Some visitors were willing to accept the carefully stage-managed picture rather than confront the evidence. “Useful idiots” all.
We should remember this history when considering Putin’s Russia. Once again, a Russian ruler denies Ukraine's right to determine its own future, seeks to erase its national identity and uses propaganda in trying to disguise ongoing aggression.
The tragedy is not merely that history repeats itself, but that the world has been given so many warnings and has so often been reluctant to heed them.
Tim Flinn, Edinburgh
Blatant hypocrisy
In October’s budget, the UK government announced a major pivot toward defence and military investments while placing tighter spending controls and capital prioritisation across other areas of government and public services. Acorn, Scotland’s only large-scale carbon capture project, has also been left out of the budget, despite the fact former Energy Secretary Ed Miliband promised it £200 million last year.
While Westminster is “prioritising delivery of mature carbon capture, usage and storage (CCUS) and hydrogen projects at the Teesside, Merseyside and North Wales clusters, maintaining grant funding for the Viking cluster”, Scotland remains the only industrial centre where grants have been replaced by dim prospects and vague promises.
Andy Burnham’s attitude towards the country raises more and more questions. When it comes to building AI data centres that could cause huge climate damage, Scotland is a great place to host them. But when it is necessary to choose whose projects should remain in the government funding programme, Scotland suddenly becomes unimportant to Westminster. How much longer can one tolerate such blatant hypocrisy?
Duncan Burgess, Inverness
Unfair assessment
Professor Ken Gibb argues correctly in Scotland on Sunday that housing tax reform is “long overdue” (“Replace ‘unfair’ council tax with ‘proportionate’ levy says expert”, 15 November).
We had the same impasse 40+ years ago when the rating system had ossified, but for electoral reasons revaluations were impossible. What followed, however, was the deeply unjust poll tax, so let's be very careful about council tax (CT) reform.
The main unfairness of CT lies in its potential penalising of home improvements and extensions. Buildings should be exempt and the whole burden placed on the site value, which is community-created through investment in roads, schools etc.
George Morton, Rosyth, Fife
Write to The Scotsman
We welcome your thoughts – NO letters submitted elsewhere, please. Write to l[email protected] including name, address and phone number – we won't print full details. Keep letters under 300 words, and in the body of the email – no attachments – and avoid 'Letters to the Editor/Readers’ Letters' or similar in your subject line. If referring to an article, include date, page number and heading. No poems.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.