Not good enough

Edinburgh has 58 salaried councillors. Approval has been given on one of the most critical city centre developments in 200 years – surely justifying a full council decision – by a vote of only eight in favour (including the planning leader) with six against (including his deputy) to a South African group for the Caltongate site (your report, 30 January).

It is described as “bland”, “torpid”, “tactless”, “inappropriate” and “ugly” by various well-known citizens, and even the planning leader effectively damned it with faint praise: it was “good enough” to be approved.

And of course, as the council already built its own headquarters there, the plan cannot include a relocated bus station adjacent to Waverley, enabling integrated transport as any self-respecting city enjoys, and despite lip-service by politicians for decades.

Sign up to our Opinion newsletter

But clearly, it’s all “good enough” for the capital for the rest of the 21st century.

John Birkett

Horseleys Park

St Andrews