Nationalism

I take seriously William Ballantine’s cautionary advice (Letters, 21 July) to be wary of “ethnic nationalism”, but respectfully disagree that it’s as simple as he describes it – that “anyone who chooses to live here can be Scottish”.

My original letter (17 July) asked whether a residency requirement of a number of years living in Scotland before entitlement to vote – at least on constitutional matters – might not be a good idea. I am open to rational debate, but no respondent has addressed this.

On the other hand, I don’t know whether to be pleased or scared that Andrew HN Gray (Letters, 21 July) has been keeping tabs on me.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It looks like he is referring to a letter years ago in which I said I was as intensely proud of my Irish (and before that Norman French) forebears, and American grandmother as I was of my English son-in law, Swedish daughter-in-law, and – how long have you got? – delightful bilingual grandchildren.

I need no lectures on temperance in matters of national pride and identity from the perennial Mr Angry of your columns. “Flush with embarrassment”?

Nope. I do flush with anger sometimes at the way my country has been – and continues to be – treated under English hegemony (aka the Union), but, in my 70s, am thrilled to know that better times for Scotland are in sight.

David Roche

Coupar Angus

Perth and Kinross

Related topics: