Male risk-taking

There seems to be something inescapably testosterone-fuelled about the SNP’s campaign to separate Scotland from the 
rest of the UK. There’s a particularly male element of risk-taking dominating it.

On any level-headed analysis, leaving the UK is an insanity for Scottish voters: the risks are staggeringly great and threaten every element of our lives. But that particularly male drive to gamble, and to leap into the unknown – if only to see what’s there – might explain why many ordinarily sane people nonetheless plan to vote Yes.

Women have been polled as much less likely to vote for independence. This must surely be linked to a lower propensity for competitive – even compulsive – risk-taking.

Sign up to our Opinion newsletter

Sign up to our Opinion newsletter

Perhaps the dose of reality that Yes voters need is less the technocratic logic of Alastair Darling than the sensible advice of a more calm-headed sister, mother, wife or girlfriend.

This decision needs to be taken with a calm head in the cold of the morning, not in the shouting atmosphere of a boys’ night out.

John Shields

Avochie, Huntly

Aberdeenshire