Living culture

Where does Joan McAlpine (Opinion, 12 July) get the absurd notion that Gaelic is "flagging" in its homeland?

Of course people from all over the world recognise its worth. Gaels went forth and populated places such as New Zealand. They were driven out by greedy landlords, who valued sheep above people. They are the diaspora, and they are welcome to their inherent culture.

Why do Runrig play to sell-out crowds in Germany and Sweden? They touch the nerves of folk who want to know where they came from: a place called Scotland.

In the Highlands and Islands, Gaelic speakers communicate with their cousins: fellow Europeans, and those who have come across the pond to find their roots. We are glad to help, and to rejoice in their company. They come to places such as Raasay, that remote island off Skye, to discover Sorley MacLean was brought up there.

Gaelic learners from elsewhere are not "foreign". They have been abroad for a while. So what? At least they have opened their eyes. Would you turn them away from your door?

ALASDAIR H MACINNES

Granton Road

Edinburgh