Future of defence

The reports on the defence cutbacks make it clear that Scotland is going to be materially affected.

The fact that it is no longer in the front line of the Cold War means that aside from a base, possibly Leuchars for fighter interceptors and aircraft training in the Scottish Highlands, there is little need for any other air bases.

Our naval shipbuilding specialises in sophisticated ships and it is clear that in the future there is going to be a smaller number of simpler ships.

The experience of Afghanistan probably means much less global involvement by our troops and we could see the number of Scottish Army troops massively reduced. Future defence is going to have to concentrate on insurgency and home-based terrorism.

Cyber-terrorism cannot be fought with carriers, destroyers, Eurofighters or ground troops.

This should all be welcomed. Defence is an expensive area and if we can make higher than average savings then it protects other, more relevant, services. The Scottish Government should recognise that we will no longer be a military nation and plan accordingly.

The communities on the Clyde and around the bases due to be closed need to be given alternative strategies. Rather than wasting time in futile posturing in the House of Commons or in the streets we need clear plans on the ground for the alternatives.

BRUCE D SKIVINGTON

Gairloch

Wester Ross