Cameron scores own goal on unionism

In doing so, he inadvertently demolished many of his own arguments against Scottish independence. Ireland and the US sought and won their independence from Britain during very different, more turbulent times, yet Britain continues to have flourishing, healthy and respectful relationships.

In Washington Mr Cameron said “the relationship between Britain and America is the strongest that it has ever been”, while announcing collaborative programmes between Britain and the US covering trade, defence, international aid, veterans’ care, climate change and much more.

Alongside Ireland’s taoiseach, Mr Cameron celebrated his belief that “the relationship between our two countries has never been stronger … our citizens, uniquely linked by history and geography, are connected today as never before through business, politics, culture and sport, travel and technology and, of course, family ties”.

In addition to initiatives on immigration, security, culture and renewable energy, both leaders also committed to protecting the common travel area that allows people to move without restriction between the two countries.

It would appear, therefore, that collaboration between an independent Scotland and the remainder of the UK on issues such as defence, shared travel areas, climate change, international aid, trade, economy and much more would not only be possible but desirable and of mutual benefit.

The contrast between this reality and the hypothetical hysteria emanating from the many anti-independence naysayers (including many of Mr Cameron’s ministers) is stark. It is also a reminder – to all sides of this debate – that it is in all of our interests for the tone around the referendum to be mutually respectful. Akin to that of future friends, neighbours and partners, perhaps.

C Hegarty

Glenorchy Road

North Berwick, East Lothian