Why Scotland faces a tough decade and what it needs to do about it – Sara Thiam, Prosper
Empowering Scotland’s regions is key to driving growth that increasingly depends on functional economic geographies, not administrative ones


For much of the devolution era, Scotland's economic debate has focused on the relationship between Holyrood and Westminster. Important as that is, another question is increasingly being asked: are decisions being made at the right level within Scotland?
Prosper has been discussing this question with leaders from business, local government, education and the third sector. Too often, the answer is no.
Today Prosper publishes Unleashing Growth in Scotland's Regions, an independent report produced with Scottish government support. Its conclusions are clear. Our regions are ambitious, optimistic and full of opportunity, but they often lack the powers, flexibility and influence they need to turn that potential into reality.
READ MORE: Call for Swinney to embrace 'Manchester model for Scotland' without radical council overhaul
The benefits of Manchesterism
This isn’t a new debate, but it now has greater urgency. Prosper has long argued Scotland needs stronger place-based partnerships and policy-making powers. Our growth blueprint calls for more power and funding to be devolved to regional and city-region partnerships, enabling them to join up decisions on skills, housing, infrastructure and public services around the needs of their local economies.
Increasingly, others are reaching the same conclusion. Across England, the devolution agenda has accelerated dramatically. Metro mayors and combined authorities now control significant powers over transport, skills, housing and economic development.
Greater Manchester has demonstrated the power of sustained regional collaboration, attracting investment, growing its labour force and strengthening economic performance over many years. As the UK government pushes ahead with a new wave of English devolution, Scotland risks seeing its regions fall behind their counterparts.
No minister can create prosperity by decree. Growth happens when businesses invest, workers gain skills, homes are built, infrastructure is delivered and public services work together.
Those things happen in regions, cities, towns and communities. Yet what we heard throughout our research was a consistent frustration that many decisions affecting regional growth remain fragmented across multiple agencies, funding streams and layers of government.
Too often, housing is considered separately from transport. Skills are disconnected from labour market demand. Infrastructure is developed without sufficient regard to workforce requirements. Investment opportunities are slowed by complicated governance and duplication.
-(1).jpeg?trim=4,2,428,0&crop=&width=640&quality=65)

Scotland’s geographical problems
The result is that Scotland's regions can see opportunities but don’t always have the tools to seize them. In Scotland’s northeast, leaders spoke about the challenge of managing a major industrial transition while retaining the energy industry’s world-class engineering expertise.
In the Highlands and Islands, there’s a once-in-a-generation opportunity, powered by renewable energy investment, yet concerns remain about housing shortages, grid constraints and infrastructure delivery. In Scotland’s south, attracting and retaining younger people to start and scale businesses was repeatedly identified as the key challenge. The Central Belt faces intensifying competition for talent and investment in advanced technologies and services.
The specifics differ. The underlying challenge does not. What Scotland needs is not another layer of bureaucracy. Indeed, that was one of the strongest messages we heard. Businesses are clear: they don’t want new structures that create further complexity.
Instead, Scotland needs a framework that allows decisions to be taken at the most effective level – sometimes national, sometimes local, but increasingly at a regional scale.
Labour markets rarely stop at council boundaries. Transport networks certainly do not. Housing and infrastructure requirements often span multiple authorities. Economic development increasingly depends on institutions working across functional economic geographies, rather than administrative ones. The principle is straightforward: decisions should sit where they can be exercised most effectively.
READ MORE: As UK economy sees ‘strikingly strong’ growth, Burnham must temper his left-wing instincts
Solutions differ from place to place
That’s why Prosper is recommending a new Regional Empowerment Bill. Such legislation should place the existing Regional Economic Partnerships, consisting of local authorities, businesses, education, enterprise agencies and the third sector, on a statutory footing, allow them to acquire additional powers where appropriate, provide greater certainty around funding and strengthen collaboration between government, business, education, trade unions and communities.
Crucially, it should not impose a one-size-fits-all model. Scotland's regions are different and their governance should reflect that.
Encouragingly, there is already momentum behind this agenda. Last year, First Minister John Swinney announced plans to introduce legislation that would allow regional partnerships to seek legal status, unlock new powers and develop governance arrangements tailored to local circumstances. Prosper believes this represents an important opportunity.
The challenge now is turning aspiration into delivery. Our research reveals that, if regional empowerment is to succeed, it must be accompanied by meaningful reform of economic development support. Competitive funding pots that encourage short-term thinking should be replaced with longer-term settlements.
National agencies should work more closely with regional priorities. Public service reform must align with economic reform. Businesses, education and third-sector organisations must be treated as partners in delivering growth.
Importantly, Scotland does not start from scratch. Many city region and regional growth deals have demonstrated their ability to bring people together. The challenge now is to evolve from partnerships focused primarily on individual projects to long-term institutions capable of driving growth.
A real opportunity
Scotland faces a difficult decade. Productivity growth has been weak. Demographic pressures are increasing. Public finances are constrained. Competition for investment is intensifying.
Meanwhile, enormous opportunities exist around clean energy, advanced manufacturing, digital technologies, life sciences and regional regeneration. Meeting those challenges and capturing those opportunities will require more than national strategies. It will require regions that are empowered to act.
Our report does not claim regional empowerment is a silver bullet. Additional powers alone will not solve housing shortages or remove every obstacle to growth – those powers must be used in the right way. But we’re convinced that giving Scotland's regions a much larger role in shaping their own economic futures is key.
The next step should be conversations about what powers should sit where, and how we create a framework that allows every region to contribute more fully to Scotland's success.
The opportunity is there. The evidence is strong. The political commitment exists. The task now is to move from discussion to delivery. If Scotland wants stronger growth, better public services and greater prosperity, we must empower our regions.
Sara Thiam is chief executive of economic think tank Prosper
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.