Scottish independence: SNP's incompetence over £3.5 billion black hole shows they are not fit to lead breakaway from UK – Murdo Fraser MSP

We tried to parry the fiasco of the ferries, a crisis that goes on. We rolled with the punch of our state-owned railways cutting journeys by a third. But there is a haymaker coming from the SNP which threatens to put Scotland on the canvas. A £3.5 billion hole in the public finances, made by Scots, in Scotland, and which will cause millions of Scots to suffer.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) estimates that is the deficit coming in our nation’s finances by 2026-27 thanks to decisions by the Scottish National Party leadership. None of the remedies is palatable.

Nicola Sturgeon will have to go cap in hand to Westminster and ask for more cash. Or try to raise taxes. Or impose savage cuts. Not Westminster cuts. Not “Tory cuts”. Homemade SNP cuts.

Hide Ad

It started when the First Minister got what she wished for and was less than careful with the powers she got. She got the power to raise income tax. In the name of her distorted vision of social justice, she made Scotland the highest taxed part of the United Kingdom.

Hide Ad

The result, as the IFS has pointed out, is that the Scottish Government has raised almost £200 million less than they would have if income tax had not been devolved. Where they predicted a £500 million gain, they have made a loss – but only noticed after they had spent it.

The SNP’s John Swinney was the first person I heard claim that unionists had said Scotland was “too stupid” to be independent. I have never heard a unionist make that argument. But he and his colleagues seem hellbent on proving the point.

Hide Ad

Whatever the constitutional arrangement, the current Cabinet in Edinburgh clearly don’t have the competence to run it. They can ask for whatever economic or political lever they care, none of them will work if the levers in their heads don’t.

Read More
The SNP sink hole will push up your cost of living in any event - Brian Monteith
Hide Ad
John Swinney and his SNP colleagues seem hellbent on proving Scotland is 'too stupid' to be independent (Picture: Fraser Bremner/pool/Getty Images)

What happens to ferry services when a £97m contract, which became a £250m budget buster meets a £3.5bn blackhole? What happens to a drastically reduced rail service when it is asked to take its share of cuts to plug a gap like that?

Hide Ad

How can failing schools do anything other than continue to fail as they are cut? How will hospital waiting times be cut when funds are cut? If this government was a patient you would call an ambulance for it, but what hope would there be that one would turn up?

Decent people who believe in independence must despair that Nicola Sturgeon seems to be making the case that Scotland cannot run itself.

Hide Ad

Sturgeon’s cuts will hurt the poorest but I am sure she will find a couple of million to fund more spin doctors to try to convince us all that it is England’s fault. Boris the bogeyman will be doubled in size.

But this homemade deficit is entirely made in Bute House. The country that once built ships now puts up with soundbites. We don’t manufacture steel, the First Minister manufactures photo opportunities. We do not engineer inventions, we engineer invented grievance.

Hide Ad

We will all pay the price for a £3.5bn hole in Scotland’s finances – caused by the fatal hole in SNP ministers’ competence.

Murdo Fraser is Scottish Conservative MSP for Mid-Scotland and Fife



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.