Former Scottish Green MSP Alison Johnstone becoming Holyrood's Presiding Officer has negated the will of the electorate – Brian Wilson

At the time of last year’s SQA fiasco, I offered words of appreciation for the role of the Greens.

OK, most of the time they acted as junior partners to the Nationalists and always made sure they got their budgets through, subject to suitable window-dressing.

Occasionally, however, they performed a useful function by joining other opposition parties to threaten the minority government with defeats. That happened over the imminent vote of no confidence in Education Secretary John Swinney and I acknowledged an occasional bulwark against one party arrogance was better than no bulwark at all.

Hide Ad

This week, the Greens voluntarily surrendered even that occasional role when one of their number, Alison Johnstone put herself forward as Presiding Officer at Holyrood. In one fell swoop, the will of the electorate not to give the SNP an overall majority has effectively been negated by Ms Johnstone choosing to neutralise herself.

Hide Ad
Read More
Scottish Greens have more power than ever, so what will they do with it? – Gina ...

There are no set rules but precedent suggested the new Presiding Officer should come from the ranks of the SNP. The last one was from an opposition party and so it was the governing party’s turn. And they have far more MSPs to choose from. But they, of course, saw the advantage of finding a patsy in the opposition ranks, and where better to look than to the Greens?

Hide Ad

Thus, one of the few checks and balances at Holyrood has been removed. Let’s see if Ms Johnstone does something useful about other failed mechanisms for holding ministers to account, starting with the committee system which was supposed to be Holyrood’s great strength but has proved to be one of its greatest weaknesses. I won’t hold my breath.

A message from the Editor:

Hide Ad
Newly elected Presiding Officer of the Scottish Parliament Alison Johnstone resigned from the Scottish Green party to take the role (Picture: Russell Cheyne/PA Wire)

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

Hide Ad

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.