Eddie Barnes: If an EU return is simply a nostalgia trip for middle-aged progressives and activists, we're better off out

Prime Minister Andy Burnham, centre, with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa at the EU-UK Summit in Brussels. ​Picture: Yves Herman/POOL/AFP via Gettyplaceholder image
Prime Minister Andy Burnham, centre, with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa at the EU-UK Summit in Brussels. ​Picture: Yves Herman/POOL/AFP via Getty

Eddie Barnes would like to see Britain back in the fold one day but it should take a lot of work, campaigning and bridge-building

Most people in this country have their personal Brexit trauma. Mine involved driving my then boss Ruth Davidson to Edinburgh early that morning as she took a call from David Cameron to let her know he was about to quit.

Sleep-deprived and discombobulated, I could barely believe what was happening. The Remain campaign’s pollsters had come into our offices a few weeks before to tell us that the result was in the bag. Ruth had turned in a bravura performance in the Wembley debate. Like the Scottish referendum, we were told voters would step back from the precipice. Except the voters thought differently. I’ve never felt so utterly blind-sided in my life.

Now, for the first time since that agonising (for me) night, there seems to be serious political heft behind the campaign to reverse the result. Fresh from signing a new deal with Brussels on Friday, Prime Minister Andy Burnham has happily encouraged talk of a potential re-entry process. The Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra has come out in favour. Last week, the former Foreign Secretary David Lammy declared he would be campaigning for Labour to support a second referendum in the party’s next manifesto. Momentum is building palpably.

I know I should be in favour of all this activity. I believe Brexit was a mistake and I wish profoundly we could wind back to the spring of that year to correct some of the mistakes of the Remain campaign and waken people from their complacency. But I look at the rush on the Labour benches to reverse 2016 and all I smell is trouble. Too many of us on my side of the fence seem to think that, with a hop and skip, we can magic Brexit away. As they did in the referendum itself, few seem to be thinking about the other side out there. Too many are wallowing in a nostalgic comfort zone, eager to return to what they see as a happier past when politics wasn’t mad, and the world was nicer, and it most things still worked.

Of course it’s understandable. These days even young people are nostalgic for that period somewhere between 10 and 15 years ago, when it was still possible to believe in a NICE (non-inflationary continuous expansion) world. If we just think it hard enough, won’t it all come back?

Unfortunately not. Those who think we can just forget Brexit ever happened and go back to a mis-remembered past are deluding themselves.

Indeed, the Rejoiner fantasy of a swift return to May 2016 was pin pricked neatly on Mr Burnham’s visit to Brussels. Member states decided to play hard ball over the cost of tuition fees for EU students in the UK. Unless the PM offered an acceptable deal to reduce them, the whole new deal was off the table, they warned. A compromise was eventually brokered but the spat served as a warning. The EU will always be zealous in the protection of its interests (and good luck to it for doing so). We’re not the lost son who will be welcomed back to the fold with forgiveness and generosity. Negotiations on rejoining will be brutal, lengthy, and penal.

We know this from the events after 2016, but some Rejoiners seem determined not to learn the lessons of the very recent past nor think through the consequences of their actions. As SNP figures have pointed out, with plenty of justification, if the EU referendum should be re-fought pronto, what about Indyref2 as well? Like buses, British referenda may decide to come in pairs. Charging speedily into a second EU referendum will only see the country flee from the centre to conduct a binary battles with battle-bus slogans, and – potentially – force an existential moment for the country.

I think and hope that Britain’s future does, eventually, sit within the European Union. For all the European Commission’s palpable faults, I think on balance it’s best for both of us. But the work that is required to get there requires far more than comfort-zone vibes from Rejoiners who just want to roll back the years and feel good again. Ironically, they might want take a leaf from the man who beat them in 2016. In his excellent new book on the referendum, “Ten Years On”, Vote Leave’s CEO Matthew Elliott reveals the painstaking strategy that, over years, led to his campaign’s success. Carefully laying down foundations, the Leave campaigners went step by meticulous step: Initially setting out a call for reform; writing detailed reports on how that might be done; building coalitions in the business community; neutralising fears about the economy; and eventually constructing a winning message – to take back control. It took years of patient work, disciplined team-building, and numerous strategic battles. It was a remarkable achievement.

If we are really serious about wanting to rejoin the EU, a similar exercise is required. Rejoiners need to build an argument. They need to win allies on the continent and think about how to find consensus with sympathetic Tories. They should think hard and icily about our negotiating position, working out how to capitalise on any EU weaknesses. Stop waving EU flags and boasting of your wholesome internationalism. Take up chess and figure out instead what’s in the British national interest.

Rejoining the EU shouldn’t be a comeback tour for middle-aged progressive politicians and activists who just want to go back to their happy place, sometime in the mid-2010s.

It deserves a more serious and thought-through effort than that. Without it, we’re best to remain out.

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice