Devastating attack on Ferguson Marine shipyard on Clyde could sound its death knell
The blame game over the long-delayed and over-budget construction of two ferries looks to be going badly for the shipyard


There has been a bitter blame game over who is responsible for the calamitous attempts to build two ferries for CalMac at the Scottish government-owned Ferguson Marine shipyard.
But the latest intervention, from Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (Cmal), the government quango that buys the ferries, was devastating. In a letter to MSPs, Cmal warned it would be “folly at worst” to award ferry contracts to the yard, and “problematic at best” because of “fundamental concerns” over value for money, delays and quality.
“The Cmal board feels strongly that the detriment to the island communities of a direct award to [Ferguson Marine] far outweighs the planned benefit to the workforce of Inverclyde,” Cmal wrote. “We understand the desire to retain jobs in the area but a combination of past performance in terms of time and costs it is difficult to see why a decision to build ferries would be made.”
‘Scotland’s ferry factory’
Willie Rennie MSP remarked that he had “never seen such a strong letter”. It is one that could, potentially, sound the yard’s death knell.
However, we should note that, four years ago, when the problems were already evident, Cmal expressed confidence in Ferguson’s capabilities, with chief executive Kevin Hobbs saying: “Would we entrust small vessels to be built at that yard? Absolutely we would.”
And Robert Deavy, of the GMB Scotland union, bemoaned people’s “short memories”, saying “Ferguson’s built a third of the current CalMac fleet and was once, not that long ago, Scotland’s ferry factory. With the right leadership and proper investment, it can again deliver a steady stream of first-class small ferries for Scotland’s islanders.”
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn suggested the government would stand by the yard, saying that maintaining commercial ship building on the Clyde was “the right political decision, not just for the islanders... but also for the workforce”. But if he is saying the yard is not to blame and is therefore worthy of more contracts, then this tacitly suggests there is merit in the case made by those who have pointed fingers at Cmal and the Scottish government.
However, unfortunately for the yard, it feels like they are currently losing the blame game.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.
