Andy Burnham‘s ‘Black Friday’ Brexit sellout will cost UK far more than it might save – Brian Monteith
Andy Burnham’s plans to move closer to the EU are unreasonable, outrageous and undemocratic


This is a big week for the Prime Minister. Having taken the reins of power with only feelgood vibes rather than a democratically endorsed mandate, he is now about to put flesh on the bare bones of his cuddly rhetoric. His intent is to build a left-of-centre consensus using progressive sentiment towards the EU that will win support from Liberal Democrat and Green voters – at the guaranteed expense of losing some of Labour colleagues in red wall seats.
On Friday, Andy Burnham attends a summit with EU leaders who have at least one thing in common with him – some also have no popular mandate from a public vote. In Brussels, he will announce measures that move Britain closer to the EU – measures that primarily are to the benefit of the EU and come at a cost to the British taxpayer and British businesses.
His first agreement (make no mistake, there will be yet more) is branded as a “reset” but it would be better described as a “reversal”. What we are seeing is the largest democratic vote in UK history being sliced away so it eventually will become meaningless.
Burnham is being crafty
Some, maybe most, Scotsman readers may think that is fine – but it is hardly democratic that a Prime Minister without a popular mandate is able to reverse a decision by over 17.4 million people without another referendum or at least first going to the country.
Last week a new campaign was launched by a group calling itself “Stay Out” with a website that hosts a slick and persuasive video about why we should not seek to join the EU for a second time.
While I share that sentiment, I must point out that Burnham is being far craftier than seeking to accede to EU membership with all the acrimonious division and annual cost of nearly £40 billion it would entail. Instead, Burnham’s programme is a ‘Black Friday’ giveaway of our parliament’s sovereign powers to make our laws.
Stay Out is responding Burnham suggesting we may one day join the EU, but it is for now a false flag, for there will be no proposal just yet, it is merely a ruse to distract from his huge giveaway of power, the increase in costs and taxes and the inevitable loss in democratic accountability.
READ MORE: Another general election! Why Labour is preparing to go to the polls early – Brian Monteith
No say in our own laws
Having created a stink about considering joining the EU, Burnham will then turn around and say, ‘but look, we haven’t rejoined, we are reasonable people’ and ‘moving closer is entirely reasonable’.
Giving away democratic accountability – the ability to determine our own laws – is not reasonable. It is worse than unreasonable – it is outrageous.
If Burnham has his way, by this time next year we shall have adopted thousands of laws that cover food standards, and animal welfare protections that are actually lower than what we have introduced for ourselves since 2020. We shall have had no say in and no veto over those laws – or in any future changes to them or any new laws introduced.
Worse still, the laws will apply to all UK businesses, irrespective of whether or not they trade with people or businesses in EU member countries. Yes, Marks and Spencer may find some savings for supplying its 18 stores in Ireland, but we shall all pay for it.
Grocers have said new border controls will bring increases to the cost of living while the increased costs to the government, not included in the recent Budget, must be paid for through higher taxes.
READ MORE: How Andy Burnham's broken Brexit pledge risks making him the new Keir Starmer – Brian Monteith
Burnham’s three tests
To build the case that Burnham is just a reasonable guy and not fraudulently giving away our self-government, he announced last night he was setting three tests by which to judge him.
The first is that his Black Friday power giveaway meets his party’s red lines set out in the 2024 general election. The manifesto said “no return to the single market” and yet his deal will apply EU rules in Britain for food, carbon and other trade – as Brussels dictates and its court adjudicates, with no veto for us. For those sectors affected, that is the single market’s rulebook without a seat at the table.
The second test says he respects what people voted for in 2016. Yet they voted to leave, so our laws are made here by people we elected and can remove, adjudicated by our own courts. Taking rules made elsewhere – extending beyond goods and into financial services was not on any ballot paper.
Third and finally Burnham cites “the Makerfield Test” of what’s good for Makerfield will be good for the UK. As I revealed last week, Survation’s polling of Burnham’s constituents, when asked who should decide on the issues to be covered by the Black Friday summit, found 74 per cent on food standards and 69 per cent on animal welfare thought these should be decided “by UK governments alone”.
On none of the ten issues questioned did more than 12 per cent think the UK should have to follow decisions of foreign politicians and judges accountable to foreign voters.
Burnham’s Black Friday Deal will fail his three tests by any measure – but it’s all optics, and illusion that will not stop him with his fire-sale of powers. And there will also be a ‘Farage clause’ whereby a future British government trying to change Burnham’s capitulation will face punitive damages. The agreement’s very own poison pill.
The Prime Minister is not being reasonable or honest with the public. His cosy ambiguities obscure sharp practice that will cost us dear; we should reject this Black Friday sell-out.
Brian Monteith is a former member of the Scottish and European parliaments and a member of Britain Unbound’s Advisory Council.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.
