Restaurant Review: We try the At Home menu from The Harbour Cafe, Elie

This East Neuk business is offering nationwide delivery of its seafoody meals

The Harbour Cafe smorgasbord
The Harbour Cafe smorgasbord

I once bought a dress by Scottish fashion designer, Jonathan Saunders, for 50p (marked down from £600) at a special online sale.

It was my finest moment. I felt immortal. Queen of the world.

People often ask me, how did you do it? My secret is, never look back.

Once the thing is in the virtual basket, click your way out of there, don’t be distracted by the other pretty pictures, your email or the phone. Focus. Hold your nerve.

Think of it like a heist, and your mouse is the getaway driver. Go!

I should have followed my own advice when ordering the new At Home menu from Elie’s Harbour Cafe, which is owned by Amy Elles of last year’s Great British Menu fame.

I’d popped their meal for two (£70), which featured two dressed half lobsters, Andalusian potato salad, langoustines, sourdough, Spanish almond tart and other lovely bits, into my online trolley. Then I had a leisurely browse of their “add-ons” - shell-shaped chocolate petit fours, organic Balcaskie rare roast beef, oh my, Arbroath Smokies, yes siree. Lobster or oysters and Champagne, quite the thing, lobster thermidor, ay get the gist.

Amy Elles

Tinkering as Rome burns.

When I went to check out, there was zilch in there.

It’s like when you miss your last train at Waverley because you’re faffing about in Valvona & Crolla.

I hope whoever ordered the last one is very pleased with themselves. Perhaps their langoustines will reanimate, and claw them on the snoot.

The Harbour Cafe, Elie

Thankfully, there were other options. I eventually settled on the smorgasbord for two (£60).

Order on Tuesday by noon for nationwide delivery, which is an additional tenner, to arrive at your doorstep on Friday. Or collect from their Elie harbour spot if you live nearby.

Our box was a real tombola of seaside treasures.

There were paper bibs, and, rolled up like treasure maps, placemats that featured their crab logo, hand wipes, sea salt with flakes of wakame, a lemon, a sprig of rosemary and wooden picks. Also, two grey stones, presumably from Elie beach.

These were multi-purpose: for cracking crab claws, weighing down the mats if you wanted to eat al-fresco, starting a campfire or using as a second home holiday cottage for slaters.

The food was neatly labelled and packaged in their compostable or biodegradable containers.

One of them contained four pink langoustines, curled up like sleeping Bagpusses.

As one of them was looking at us funny with those beady eyes, we pulled its cheeky head off, and the other got the same treatment. Their meat was sweet and so crystalline fresh that you could imagine their antennae were still twitching.

We ate this option solo, though I suppose we should have had them with the aioli. Instead, we used this thick garlicky condiment to ice our fat clutch of about a dozen naked pre-cooked mussels, which we’d decanted from their vacuum pack.

There were also half a dozen pork meatballs, to be nuked in the microwavé (as Nigella recently called it) along with their magnolia-coloured creamy gravy, a large dollop of silky mashed potato, and a blob of lingonberry jam.

That was good, but four slices of trout gravadlax, with edges feathered by dill, were the best bit.

We had these alongside the lightly pickled cucumbers, cut into shapes like Trivial Pursuit wedges, as well as cardboard coloured and crispy sheets of knackebrod.

We were actually feeling quite knackebrod at this point, what with the endless eating. There was probably enough to feed three.

There were still two little whorls of rollmop pickled herring, which I snaffled like a selkie, and a single fillet of caramel-hued smoked mackerel to share, with two sauces on the side - beetroot horseradish and a tangy honey mustard.

Despite the initial disappointment, things had worked out pretty nicely for me.

I’m a fan of smorgasbords when they’re as good as this, though I’m still a bit sad about not getting to try their Spanish almond tart.

Oh well, let’s hope the other shopper has managed to prise that langoustine off their face.

Harbour Cafe

The Toft

Elie Harbour


The Verdict

How much? Dinner for two, £60 (plus a £10 delivery charge), excluding drinks

Food: 7.5/10

Ambience: 7.5/10

Total: 15/20

Places to Try Nearby

The Dory Bistro & Gallery, 15 East Shore, Pittenweem (01333 311 222,

Here’s another gem with a harbour view, and takeaways to collect. Their new Dining at Home menu has courses including spiced buttermilk hake with dhal, baby spinach and herb rice, as well as a pre-starter course of crispy Cumbrae “angels on horseback” oysters, cucumber and dill pickle.

Craig Millar @ 16 West End, St Monans Fife (

Once things are more normal, we’ll be straight along to this restaurant - one of our all-time faves, with its view out to the harbour. They’ve been dabbling in takeaway, including a twice baked Mull Cheddar souffle, so it’s worth checking their Facebook page for updates.

Kinneuchar Inn, 9-11 Main Street, Kilconquhar, Fife (01333 340 377,

We’ve raved about this place so much since it opened that it’s starting to get embarrassing. Check out their website for the Kinneuchar at Home menu, which features rib-sticking dishes including the chicken and smoked ham pie, lamb curry and a Reuben milk bun filled with salt beef, sauerkraut, pickled cucumber and thousand island dressing.

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.