Edinburgh whisky fan pips wife to be crowned blind-tasting champion
The winner of the Scotch Malt Whisky Society (SMWS) competition secured victory by correctly identifying eight out of 11 whiskies with no label, age or distillery name.
With whisky season getting into full swing, a project manager in finance has been crowned the winner of a new blind tasting whisky competition in Edinburgh – beating his wife Kirsty to victory.
Alan Scott, 43, from Edinburgh won the inaugural Caskmaster competition which was staged by The Scotch Malt Whisky Society in Edinburgh. The Society, which is a whisky club and independent bottler that was set up in 1983, encourages people to approach whisky through the lens of flavour rather than traditional elements such as distillery name, region and age.
The 19 finalists gathered at The Vaults in Leith, the Society’s spiritual home, for the Grand Final, following four heats in Edinburgh, Glasgow and London.
The competition, which was open to all, was decided over two rounds of blind tasting. In the first, finalists had 30 minutes to nose and taste eight unmarked whiskies and match each one to a lineup of nine, with no conferring allowed.
The second round upped the pressure, where seven contestants had just 10 minutes to identify three unmarked whiskies from a lineup of six. The whiskies in the final ranged from 14 to 26 years old and were selected from the Society’s range of eight flavour profiles.


Alan, whose wife Kirsty came second after winning The Vaults heat, was then announced as champion in the Members’ Room, which is usually reserved for Society members but was opened up to guests especially for the night.
In being crowned champion, he won a lifetime membership of the Society and a place on a four-day whisky trip to Speyside in March 2027, hosted by Mitch Bechard of CopperCairn, a Keeper of the Quaich, author and host of Not Another Whisky Podcast.
Celebrating his win, Scott said: “I wasn’t confident I was going to win at all, but I’ve tried a fair amount of whisky, so I knew I wasn’t going to come last. I think there’s always a bit of luck, because certain people gravitate towards certain distilleries.
“I was mostly just nosing the whisky as much as possible. With eight drams, you nose as much as you can until your nose starts to go, pick based on that, then see if tasting it matches up with what you’re nosing."
Calum Lawson, member experience manager at SMWS, said: “Blind tasting is great fun, but it’s also hard. When you take away things like distillery names, ages and so on, all you’ve got to go on is what’s in the glass, and it can be humbling.
“Alan has a remarkable nose. To get this right, you have to pick up tiny differences in smell and taste and trust your instincts when two whiskies seem almost identical. He did that better than anyone on the night, although obviously Kirsty did exceptionally well too.”
The Society was started in Edinburgh by a group of friends who shared a cask of single malt between them. It now has more than 40,000 members around the world and selects single casks from distilleries across Scotland and beyond, giving each a number and a descriptive name instead of the distillery’s, such as Red Wine and Brine in the Old Coal Mine.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.