Jacobite society warns of 'irreparable damage' to historic battlefield amid A9 upgrade plan

A depiction of the Battle of Killiecrankie of 1689. A public inquiry is now underway to determine if the A9 can be dualled over the site of the Jacobite victory.  PIC: Shutterstock.
A depiction of the Battle of Killiecrankie of 1689. A public inquiry is now underway to determine if the A9 can be dualled over the site of the Jacobite victory. PIC: Shutterstock.
Share this article
Have your say

A Jacobite society has spoken out against dualling the A9 trunk road over the site of the 1689 Battle of Killiecrankie.

The 1745 Association said plans by Transport Scotland to widen the existing route over the battlefield risked “irreparable and irreversible damage” to the important historic site.

READ MORE: The seized Jacobite land and money that helped build Scotland
The comments came as a public local inquiry opened in Pitlochry yesterday to examine objections to the proposals.

Michael Nevin, chairman of the 1745 Association said: “We are respectfully asking the Reporter to consider all feasible options for the A9, not just those put forward by Transport for Scotland, in order to avoid irreparable and irreversible damage to one of Scotland’s most important battlefield sites.”

Mr Nevin said the best strategy for the A9 would involve maintaining the existing single carriageway at the Pass of Killiecrankie, combined with selective dualling on stretches before and after, allowing motorists to overtake slower moving vehicles safely.

READ MORE: The Jacobites who fought on after Culloden
He said: “At Killiecrankie, a far more cost-effective option would involve maintaining the existing single carriageway, adding a lay-by together and enhancing battlefield interpretation to encourage passing travellers by bus, coach and car to pause and reflect on an important moment in Scottish history.”

The 1745 Association formally wrote to the Director of Major Transport Infrastructure Projects of Transport Scotland in January 2018 setting out its objections.

Mr Nevin said “cosmetic changes” since drawn up by Transport Scotland did not go far enough to allay the association’s concerns.

“We stand shoulder to shoulder with the Scottish Battlefields Trust, the local community group Soldiers of Killiecrankie, our friends in The Fifteen (the Northumbrian Jacobite Society) and many others who share our fundamental concerns about these proposals,” he said.

Much of the campaign against the expansion of the road over the battlefield, where a Jacobite force of roughly half the size of the British Army contingent claimed victory in the major encounter of the first rising, has been fought by the Killiecrankie1689 organisation.

A statement on the group’s website said it was in favour of the A9 upgrade, but claimed there was not enough proof the plan for the battlefield was the best one available.

The statement said: “Scotland once aspired to be seen as an international exemplar of how a small country can care for its historic environment. This scheme betrays that aspiration. No-one relishes the prospect of an inquiry.

However, it is the only way we have to examine the opaque process and decisions that informed the choice of design and alignment of the proposed scheme.”

The public local inquiry in Pitlochry is expected to last two weeks.

A Transport Scotland spokesperson said: “We are aware of the sensitivities around what is an important battlefield and site of historical and cultural significance, which is why we have been engaging extensively with the local community and key stakeholders since 2012.”

He said amendments had been made to their proposals to reduce the amount of battlefield land being given over to the new road.