NHS Grampian facing ‘millions’ in compensation payouts as families consider legal claims

Lawyer Aamer Anwar and Dr Mohammed Habib.placeholder image
Lawyer Aamer Anwar and Dr Mohammed Habib. | John Devlin/The Scotsman

Lawyers described revelations surrounding standards at NHS Grampian as ‘the stuff of nightmares’ as families come forward re potential claims

NHS Grampian could have to pay out £100 million to bereaved families as several look to launch medical negligence claims against the health board, lawyers have claimed.

On Thursday, whistleblowing surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib, who works at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, called for criminal charges to be brought against the health board, and claims there were multiple deaths caused by “wicked recklessness”.

He shared the findings of a review, instructed by NHS Grampian in September 2022, of 45 liver and pancreatic surgery cases which found there were 19 avoidable deaths among the 31 who died between 2015 and 2021.

Lawyer Aamer Anwar and Dr Mohammed Habib.placeholder image
Lawyer Aamer Anwar and Dr Mohammed Habib. | John Devlin/The Scotsman

Now two leading Scottish law firms have confirmed they have been contacted by several bereaved families looking to launch claims against NHS Grampian. The health board could end up paying out in excess of £100m.

Patrick McGuire, senior partner at Thompsons Solicitors, said: “What has been laid bare by Dr Habib in his explosive and courageous conference is the stuff of nightmares more suited to some Dickensian sick house rather than a hospital in 21st century Scotland.

“My team has already started receiving initial enquiries from families affected and is setting up a dedicated phone line and dedicated legal team to deal specifically with this case.

“I have dealt with many shocking NHS scandals over the past 30 years and this has all the hallmarks of huge malpractice and a huge cover-up. NHS Grampian need to prepare themselves.”

He added: “It’s already clear that compensation payments will exceed £10m. By the time the full extent of the scandal is known, I fully expect the compensation levels to exceed £100m.”

Meanwhile Trish McFadden, partner and clinical negligence specialist at Digby Brown, said: “The reports coming out about NHS Grampian are understandably shocking to all patients in that area.

“In this day and age people should trust when they go to hospital they will receive the best care and treatment.

“There will no doubt be many people questioning what their legal rights are if they were affected by the issues outlined in the recent review from Healthcare Improvement Scotland and it’s important they seek independent legal advice to be sure.

“We have already been contacted by many affected by the NHS Grampian scandal and our early investigations show the key to securing a fair outcome is if they have been contacted by the health board directly and received a letter of apology or adverse event review report that may outline any key failings in their own treatment.”

She said: “I do, because the history of some of the very distressing issues predate her appointment.”

Health Secretary Angela Constanceplaceholder image
Health Secretary Angela Constance | Jane Barlow/Press Association

When asked when she first learned of Dr Habib’s claims, she said: “So I found out yesterday, that was the first time I had seen his correspondence.”

This is despite Dr Habib raising issues with senior NHS bosses and government ministers for a decade. He said he has previously written to First Minister John Swinney, former first minister Humza Yousaf, and former health secretaries Michael Matheson and Neil Gray.

On Thursday, Dr Habib told a press conference: “These cases relating to ARI are, I believe, due to poor decision making, poor technique and recklessness, and they are tantamount to corporate homicide.

“In all the cases that I reported, they were in my opinion guilty of wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient death as an outcome.

“NHS Grampian knew enough to have stopped this carnage.”

First Minister John Swinney said he had not been made aware of the letters sent by Dr Habib until they were made public on Thursday.

Mr Swinney has instructed Scotland’s most senior civil servant, Joe Griffin, to conduct a review into the handling of correspondence sent to the Government.

Scottish Labour said families impacted by the scandal at NHS Grampian needed answers, not “dither and delay” from ministers.

Scottish Labour deputy leader Dame Jackie Baillie said there had been a “monumental failure of governance, with devastating consequences”.

She added: “The facts are that 19 people in the care of our NHS died when they should not have.

“We now know that serious concerns were being raised about avoidable deaths, with a paper trail showing correspondence with Scottish Government officials and Police Scotland.

“Despite this, no action was taken, Aberdeen Royal Infirmary continued to operate as normal, and patients were left in the dark.

“It is not good enough for Angela Constance to dither and delay, while families are without the transparency they need.

“That is why we have written to the Scottish Government to seek the urgent answers they need and deserve.”

The party has tabled 23 questions at Holyrood on the issues facing NHS Grampian.

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has also accused the Government of failing to act on the situation.

In a letter to the First Minister, Mr Findlay said: “This represents a sickening, and potentially criminal, betrayal of innocent patients and their families.

“The disgusting cover-up that ensued risks destroying the trust of the paying public and does a gross disservice to the vast majority of heroic NHS staff who work tirelessly to deliver effective and compassionate care.”

Mr Findlay also asked six questions of the First Minister, including calling on him to publish all correspondence between the Government and the health board, as well as urgently ordering NHS Grampian to preserve documents.

It came a week after the publication of a damning report about the health board, following which Ms Constance said a specialist team had been sent in to NHS Grampian to provide “intensive turnaround support”.

The report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland found “serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across the acute sector of NHS Grampian”.

Police Scotland confirmed on Thursday it received a report in 2024 regarding “several deaths” within the healthboard area.

Enquiries are ongoing.

NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said a “thorough investigation” has already taken place into some of the issues raised by Dr Habib, with “some elements of that work ongoing “.

She added: “Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.

“We understand the allegations will cause further concern to patients, members of the public and staff.

“It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed.

“This includes direct communication with patients and families where required.

“If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so. Patient safety remains our highest priority.”

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice