Here, we take a look at some of the Scottish secondary schools which are outperforming government-set benchmarks for the proportion of pupils passing five or more Highers.
League tables are often seen as a blunt instrument to measure exam performance by as they fail to take into account the types of pupil attending each school.
As a result, the Scottish Government sets benchmarks to take into account the types of pupils attending the school.
Schools are each given a ‘virtual comparator’ - a group of pupils from elsewhere in Scotland with the same characteristics as the pupils in the school, in terms of their gender, the number with additional support needs and societal factors such as deprivation levels. The attainment levels of this comparator group is then used as a benchmark to measure the school’s actual performance against.
Across Scotland, 41 per cent of schools had more pupils getting five or more Highers than their virtual comparator, while 52 per cent scored worse than their benchmark and the rest scored the same.
Here are the 12 schools in Scotland which performed best against their ‘virtual comparator’.




1. Whitburn Academy
At Whitburn Academy, in West Lothian, 55 per cent of pupils left with at least five Highers in 2022. This is a huge 34 percentage points better than its virtual comparator. Photo: Google Maps

2. Moffat Academy
At Moffat Academy, in Dumfries & Galloway, 65 per cent of pupils left with at least five Highers in 2022. This is 20 percentage points better than its virtual comparator. Photo: Google Maps

3. Barrhead High School
At Barrhead High School, in East Renfrewshire, 55 per cent of pupils left with at least five Highers in 2022. This is 19 percentage points better than its virtual comparator. Photo: Google Maps

4. Jordanhill School
At Jordanhill School, in Glasgow City, 89 per cent of pupils left with at least five Highers in 2022. This is 19 percentage points better than its virtual comparator. Photo: Google Maps