Experts warn savers to be wary of cashing in '˜gold-plated' pensions

Pensions that promise savers a certain level of income when they retire are highly prized and increasingly rare. But recently there's been a surge in people looking to exchange the promise of a regular pension in retirement for a large amount of money.
Since 2015, over-55s have had much more flexibility over how they use their pension pot.Since 2015, over-55s have had much more flexibility over how they use their pension pot.
Since 2015, over-55s have had much more flexibility over how they use their pension pot.

Here’s a look at what’s been happening and why the pros and cons should be carefully weighed up.

What are the different pension types?

Defined benefit (DB) pensions are often described as “gold-plated” because they guarantee holders will end up with a certain level of pension income, such as final salary pensions.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But they have increasingly been replaced by defined contribution (DC) schemes, as firms have found DB schemes expensive to run as people are living longer and spending more years in retirement.

While DB schemes offer a set retirement income, savers in a DC scheme generally bear the risk of how much retirement income they’ll eventually end up with.

What’s changed recently?

The pension freedoms, introduced in 2015, allow over-55s with DC pensions to have much more flexibility over how they use their pension pot. Whereas previously they may have been required to use their pot to buy a retirement income called an annuity, now they have a much wider range of options. This widened level of choice may increase the attractiveness of DC schemes.

What are the pension trends?

Research from Royal London among more than 800 financial advisers found a big increase in transfers out of final salary pensions.

There are big sums involved too. Royal London found growth of more than 50 per cent in the volume of transfers out of final salary pensions taking place in the past year, with the most common transfer value lying in the £250,000 to £500,000 range.

One in four advisers reported most of the transfers they deal with are worth 30 to 40 times the annual pension foregone.

What could the pros
and cons be?

It’s important for savers to think carefully beforehand about what they would be giving up. Baroness Ros Altmann, a former pensions minister, says: “It is vital to get good advice first.” She says possible reasons for someone transferring could include:

 They have very large debts and the money could help pay them off.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

 They have several DB pensions and could transfer some and still have a guaranteed income.

 They are in poor health and fear dying young.

 They are comfortable with managing money or finding someone to do that for them.

 They want a fund to help pay for care if needed.

On the other hand, reasons someone may want to stay in a scheme could include:

 They are worried the decision is irreversible and they might regret it.

 The scheme is their only pension.

 They value the peace of mind of a guaranteed income.

 They are concerned about inflation and have an inflation-linked DB pension.

What else should savers consider?

Savers should beware of pensions and investments scams. The Financial Conduct Authority’s website has tips to spot signs of fraud at The FCA also lists authorised firms at