SCO Chorus Christmas Concert, Greyfriars Kirk, Edinburgh *****
But despite the concert’s nods to Christmas favourites – a tender, careful Rocking Carol, a velvety, caressing Away in a Manger, a supple In the Bleak Midwinter – what really impressed was Batsleer’s overall conception for the evening.
His first half – performed straight through, with no applause, he requested – alternated movements from Rachmaninov’s Vespers with seasonal songs from across Europe, some familiar, others less so. His second half brought in more challenging works by Pärt and Tavener, nestling among Tchaikovsky and Grieg.
The result was a deeply rewarding, absorbing evening of music, immaculately judged in its shifting moods and perspectives, and one that provided – as Batsleer also said he hoped – a time for reflection amid the pre-Christmas hubbub.
The SCO Chorus singers were on breathtaking form – rich and resonant in the Rachmaninov movements (though, perhaps inevitably, somewhat light in the composer’s abyssal basslines), swelling with emotion in Tchaikovsky’s The Crown of Roses, superbly balanced in the restlessly changing textures of Grieg’s Ave Maris Stella.
As the Chorus encircled the audience in Greyfriars Kirk for a surround-sound account of Tavener’s brief but potent Hymn to the Mother of God, it felt like a grand but also touchingly intimate climax to a thoughtful, thought-provoking evening. - DAVID KETTLE