Massive offshore wind farm would ruin Scots island idyll, warns duke

The Duke of Argyll believes Tiree, off the west coast of Scotland, will "never be the same again" if the 500-turbine Argyll Array wind farm is built.

The island, where just 750 people live, forms part of Torquhil Ian Campbell's estate.

The 13th Duke of Argyll, whose family seat is Inveraray Castle, has spoken up for island residents concerned about the impacts of building the 6 billion scheme.

Andrew Montgomery, who represents the Duke, said: "I don't think Tiree could be the same again and personally I think that would be a great shame.

"People go to Tiree because of its unspoilt beauty. Two people have already said they will move off the island." He added: "The view from the island would be damaged and businesses will suffer. Most people won't want to stay in a guest house with a view of a 500-turbine wind farm."

He warned the island's infrastructure, including the water supply, could already "hardly cope", without having to cater to a fresh influx of people.

And he fears there would be a "clash" between incomers moving from the mainland to work on Tiree and existing residents.

He thinks the wind farm workers should be housed on an offshore rig, rather than on the island.

Mr Montgomery said his views mirrored those of the Duke. "He has spoken to me about it and he has the same opinions. He enjoys Tiree. His family go there every year for a holiday and they don't want to lose that."

ScottishPower Renewables has been given leasing rights for the stretch of ocean about three miles to the west of Tiree by the Crown Estate, which is responsible for the seas around Scotland.

The firm is expected to lodge a planning application in 2012, following a lengthy consultation process, and if consent is granted the wind farm could start operating as soon as 2014.

It is estimated the scheme could provide enough power for a fifth of Scotland's electricity needs. Between 300 and 500 giant offshore turbines would be up to 450 ft tall - three times the height of local landmark the Skerryvore Lighthouse.

About 150 people attended a recent meeting on the island to discuss the impacts of the wind farm.Karl Hughes is among local residents who fear work to build the giant project will bring disruption, noise, helicopter flights, wider roads and new houses.

Mr Hughes, who moved to Tiree 12 years ago, where his two children were born, said: "Unless a serious effort is made to protect the lifestyle of the islanders, and the natural beauty of Tiree itself this project will be a 'shame' for Scotland, in a very similar vein as North Sea oil was and still is."

However, opinion on the island is divided, with some people relishing the idea of new job opportunities.

Local councillor Donald McIntosh believes the wind farm would bring economic benefits.

He said it was important to remember the "bigger picture" that it could provide 20 per cent of Scotland's power. And it would create jobs at a time when young people on Scottish islands were struggling to find work.

Argyll and Bute councillor Len Scoular, who also represents Tiree, said: "We don't want to upset life for the people of Tiree.

"It could help the economy of Tiree but it must not in the process destroy the way of life."

A spokesman for ScottishPower Renewables said: "We have a very good reputation for working with communities and being a responsible developer."