DCSIMG
SWTS.news.image.e

Opinion rss

Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon at Alexander Dennis Limited on Tuesday. Picture: PA

Alf Young: Power about more than mechanics

WHEN Scotland’s First Minister stood before a group of workers in a Falkirk factory on Tuesday to launch his government’s economic case for independence, Alex Salmond used a well-worn phrase.

8 comments

Author James Salter. Picture: Getty

Stephen McGinty: Respect, all that is needed

WHEN James Salter was 79-years old he was invited to fly in an F-16 by an American Air Force general, who admired his novel The Hunters about pilots in Korea where Salter had flown over 100 missions in the early 1950s.

Britain came within six hours of running out of gas in March. Picture: PA

Leaders: Political assurances on gas just hot air

NOW we know. Because a water pump failed, Britain came within six hours of running out of gas in March.

1 comment

Coffee was introduced to the UK from North Africa via Venetian merchants in the 17th century. Picture: TSPL

Erikka Askeland: Drinking in caffeine culture

I AM a drug addict. When I get my fix, I get a sense of mild euphoria and well-being.

3 comments

Monachyle Mhor's Tom Lewis. Picture: Contributed

Stephen Jardine: Two events worth braving elements

WHEN it comes to public displays of bravery, organising an outdoor food event in Scotland is right up there with putting your head in the mouth of a killer whale.

Social justice in an independent Scotland has been a subject of discussion. Picture: Phil Wilkinson

Gerry Hassan: Not social justice paradise we claim

THERE was a revealing exchange on Newsnight Scotland this week which got to the heart of the matter of the substance (or lack of) in much of the independence debate.

13 comments

On this day: Strachan resigns at Celtic | Bank Holiday Act passed

Events, birthdays and anniversaries from 25 May

SLTs play a vital role in meeting the growing needs of Scotland's ageing adult population. Picture: Getty

Kim Hartley: Professional teams key for healthcare

SPEECH and language therapists (SLTs), play a vital role in meeting the growing needs of Scotland’s ageing adult population.

Lori Anderson observes that learning to cook is the most important thing an 'ordinary person' can do to reform the food system. Picture: TSPL

Lori Anderson: Cook your way towards a healthy life

I WAS raised on a diet of tinned everything; I was born of the loins of a mother for whom the domestic arts were as arcane as Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason.

Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Salmond launched Scotlands Economy: The Case for Independence, which is half right but doesnt join the dots. Picture: PA

Robin McAlpine: Economy plan chained by convention

The SNP’s plan, while recognising some of what not to do, seems to include repeating the mistakes that caused the economic crisis in the first place, writes Robin McAlpine

16 comments

David Bell: Reform is game changer for renewables

On 30 April the Scottish Government launched a consultation on an overhaul of national planning policy, with the issue of a draft Scottish Planning Policy (SPP) and the third National Planning Framework (NPF 3).

7 comments

Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson. Picture: PA

Tom Peterkin: Rift within Scots Tories deepens

AS IF a divided Conservative Party did not have enough on its plate already – what with the widening fissure over Europe and divisions over the gay marriage issue.

3 comments

Treasury analysis suggesting an independent Scotland would be weaker is a 'tendentious and mendacious'. Picture: Getty

George Kerevan: UK Treasury in choppy waters

In questioning Scotland’s ability to weather an economic storm the Treasury is sailing rather close to the wind, writes George Kerevan

22 comments

John Kerry and Benjamin Netenyahu. Picture: Reuters

Analysis: Netanyahu unlikely to give Kerry peace

Seeking to nudge Israelis and Palestinians back to the negotiating table, US Secretary of State John Kerry this week praised Israeli premier Benjamin Netanyahu’s “seriousness” about revitalising hopes for a peace deal and voiced optimism for ending years of stalemate.

Juliet Dunlop. Picture: TSPL

Juliet Dunlop: Holidays at home win – by a distance

Does the thought of a fortnight in the sun fill you with dread? Do you break out in a cold sweat at the merest mention of a long-haul flight?

Tributes left for the soldier killed in Woolwich. Picture: Getty

Leaders: What price for vigilance? | Weather woes

It WAS one of those news items you have to catch twice because its horror was hard to believe the first time.

Chief Superintendent David OConnor argues that 14 is the logical number based on police divisions. Picture: Jane Barlow

Richard Kerley: Centralisation claims don’t add up

The argument that more centralisation of public resources will save money is not based on hard evidence, writes Richard Kerley

1 comment

Ordinary Londoners, not politicians, will ensure their city remains a dynamic multicultural community. Picture: Reuters

Joyce McMillan: Politics of hate achieve nothing

Our reaction to the events in Woolwich must not mirror the mindset of the criminals, writes Joyce McMillan

16 comments

Party leader Ruth Davidson has changed her stance on the Scottish Parliament. Picture: Phil Wilkinson

Murdo Fraser: Scottish Tories move with the times

A shift to embrace further powers for Holyrood will put party back at the heart of the political landscape, writes Murdo Fraser

23 comments

Preston Lodge High School pupils size up each other's uniforms. Picture: TSPL

Fiona McCade: Popularity comes at too high a price

When I was about seven years old, I remember being sent out of class for sobbing uncontrollably. Why? Because I was wearing woolly tights.

2 comments

Police forensics tents and officers are seen in Woolwich, east London. Picture: Getty

Analysis: Woolwich a ‘new round of terror threats’

Terrorist experts said yesterday’s murder was a departure from previous attacks and represented a “new round of terror threats in this country”.

Peter MacLeod: Children in care deserve equal chance

DISCRIMINATION against children and young people in care affects around 16,000 youngsters a year in Scotland and costs the taxpayer millions because of the pressure it puts on prisons and the welfare system.

Tavish Scott. Picture: PA

Tavish Scott: SNP needs to send positive message

This week, the independence debate featured claim and counter claim. So, too, in the previous week.

34 comments

An officer holds a notepad in Edinburgh. Picture: Ian Georgeson

Michael Kelly: Police have right to quiz services

With the advent of devolution, is there still a role for local government to play, asks Michael Kelly

5 comments

George Osborne attends an IMF press conference today. Picture: Getty

Leaders: George Osborne’s Plan B | Poor healthcare

WHILE David Cameron was embarked on his latest round of diplomacy in Europe to try to get EU agreement on tackling tax avoidance by multinational companies, his Chancellor, George Osborne, was back in London responding to the report on the UK economy by the International Monetary Fund.

The independence argument relies heavily on North Sea oil revenues, but they are in long-term decline. Picture: Hamish Campbell

Bill Jamieson: Get real about our debt problems

The independence debate has avoided the subject of our economy – but it must be confronted, writes Bill Jamieson

61 comments

An artist's impression of the Oyster wave energy machine in operation

Analysis: Marine energy hampered by costs

THE renewables industry often talks about Scotland’s marine energy sector as “world-leading” and it is announcements like this from Aquamarine Power that help prove the point.

7 comments

Haddingtons cheerleaders claim the SNP plans will have a major effect on the towns regeneration efforts. Picture: Jeremy Stockton

Iain Gray: SNP closures court disaster

There is no justice in SNP plans to close 26 courts – a decision that will a have a serious knock-on effect 
on the viability of our towns, writes Iain Gray

20 comments

Commissioners leave the church as the heavens opened in Edinburgh yesterday. Picture: Phil Wilkinson

Allan Massie: Indy debate should follow Kirk lead

Nationalists and unionists would do well to heed respect shown by both sides to prepare ground for reconciliation, writes Allan Massie

13 comments

TV presenter Kate Garraway with daughter Darcy in 2006. Picture: PA

Emma Cowing: Fertility drive is offensive to women

KATE Garraway, her off Daybreak who is married to Derek Draper, is fronting a new campaign called Get Britain Fertile. It features Garraway made up to look like she’s about 102, sporting an enormous baby bump.

2 comments

Milo Dukanovic led Montenegros secession from Yugoslavia by plucking the national heartstrings of his people. Picture: AFP/Getty Images

Matt Qvortrup: Emotions will rule on independence

The case either for or against independence will be won not by economic reason but by matching people’s passions, writes Matt Qvortrup

11 comments

Chancellor George Osborne. Picture: Getty

Eddie Barnes: George Osborne and IMF go to-to-toe

FOR the past few weeks, George Osborne has been getting his annual health check.

1 comment

TV presenter Kate Garraway with daughter Darcy in 2006. Picture: PA

Emma Cowing: Fertility drive is offensive to women

KATE Garraway, her off Daybreak who is married to Derek Draper, is fronting a new campaign called Get Britain Fertile. It features Garraway made up to look like she’s about 102, sporting an enormous baby bump.

1 comment

Scotland welcomes you  but for how long will it be easy just to step over the border? Picture: Neil Hanna

Brian Wilson: SNP plans border on the ridiculous

SNP policy on immigration would inevitably lead to the setting up of checks and controls, writes Brian Wilson

83 comments

Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon. Picture: Getty

Leaders: Salmond must flesh out case | Andy’s granny

IF THE document on the Scottish economy published yesterday by Alex Salmond was an attempt to regain the independence initiative after a series of set-backs, it looks to have been at best a damp squib and at worst a failure.

8 comments

Productions of Wagners work are always lavish, as in this performance by Scottish Opera. Picture: David Cheskin/PA

Michael Fry: Wagner remains meister of controversy

On the 200th anniversary of Richard Wagner’s birth, opinion remains deeply divided over whether the quality of his music outweighs his unpalatable views on Jews, writes Michael Fry

3 comments

Lebanese and Syrians take part in a demonstration against Hezbollah's military interference in Syria. Picture: Getty

David Martin: Everyone can help ease Syria crisis

There is little the European Union can do to bring a military solution to the crisis in Syria. But that does not mean we should sit back and wring our hands in anguish.

Alex Salmond speaks to pensioners in Bannockburn, Stirling in 2011. Picture: Ian Rutherford

Comment:Scottish independence and pensions outlook

Pensions are rapidly looking like being the key vote-determining issue of the independence referendum. And for the SNP right now, it looks like being a real killer. Unless Alex Salmond can come up with some really convincing evidence and arguments to show that pensions will be not just safe, but also better, in an independent Scotland, then he will lose the referendum.

21 comments

Rev Albert Bogle addresses the floor. Picture: Phil Wilkinson

Analysis: Small but significant step for Kirk

To a slightly bemused watching world, the pace with which the Church of Scotland is facing up to issues of sexuality seems painfully slow.

'So far, the Better Together side has only made brief forays into emotional argument for Scotland staying in the UK' Picture: Phil Wilkinson

David Maddox: Independence referendum will leave emotional scars

WITH the latest UK government paper out yesterday saying why Scottish independence really is not a good idea, it is easy to forget the emotional side in the trading and counter-trading of facts and non-facts across the two sides of the debate.

17 comments

Human rights activists outside the White House in 2011. Picture: AP

Jackie Kemp: Guantanamo bloody stain on US values

Obama’s broken promises may prove a turning point in support for US, says Jackie Kemp

1 comment

Could classrooms benefit from having more male teachers? Picture: PA

Hugh Reilly: Teaching profession needs to man up

When I joined Strathclyde Police in 1975, many of my older colleagues hailed from the Highlands or one of the many Hebridean gulag archipelagos.

3 comments

Brian Wilson: Millport marine centre must be saved

On one Scottish island, there is a centre of academic excellence which predates the University of the Highlands and Islands by fully a century. That island is Cumbrae in the Firth of Clyde.

1 comment

Tony Blair celebrates with voters in Parliament Square, Edinburgh, after Scotland voted Yes/Yes vote in 1997. Picture: Allan Milligan

Brian Taylor: Labour’s home rule battle

In the last of our series in association with the University of Glasgow’s Vox Populi lectures, Brian Taylor looks back at the referendum of 1997

13 comments

Rankins exhibition, which features a portrait of Sandra Barber, who has a brain tumour, is the latest to focus on terminal illness. Picture: Rankin

Tiffany Jenkins: Why the fascination with death?

Celebrity photographer Rankin has snapped the most attractive and famous people in the world: Kate Moss, Scarlett Johansson, Daniel Craig and George Clooney are just some of the beautiful people he has immortalised in their prime.

1 comment

General Assembly of the Church of Scotland debate the issue of gay ministers. Picture: Phil Wilkinson

Leaders: Kirk’s gay ministers ruling | Drink proposals

Religious convictions, because they derive from faith in the Word of God as revealed in the Bible, are the most unshakeable of beliefs.

7 comments

Ukip leader Nigel Farage. Picture: PA

Brian Monteith: Free speech right applies to Farage

If Scotland is ‘better’ than the rest of the UK, then Salmond should be condemning Ukip’s treatment here, writes Brian Monteith

47 comments

The Church of Scotland could learn from actress Angelina Jolies decisiveness and bravery. Picture: AFP/Getty

Lesley Riddoch: Kirk gay debate must show courage

The General Assembly has the chance to show that it too can take hard decisions without flinching, writes Lesley Riddoch

13 comments

Picture: Ian Rutherford

Comment: Scotland needs free cancer drug access

Last week at the Scottish Parliament, the presence of bowel cancer patient Maureen Fleming at First Minister’s Questions presented every single MSP in the chamber with a challenge: why are patients in Scotland three times less likely than patients in England to get access to cancer medicines, prescribed by their doctor but not routinely funded through the NHS?

6 comments

Royal Bank of Scotland's Gogarburn headquarters in Edinburgh. Picture: Neil Hanna

Leaders: Good reasons for demonisation of bankers

Has the time come to halt the demonisation of bankers? Outgoing Bank of England governor Sir Mervyn King thinks so. His point is not simply that it has gone on long enough and that it is time to move on.

Find It

"Business owner? - Claim your business and Advertise with us"

In association with qype logo

Looking for...

Featured advertisers

Jobs

Search for a job

Motors

Search for a car

Property

Search for a house

Weather for Edinburgh

Saturday 25 May 2013

5 day forecast

Today

Sunny

Sunny

Temperature: 6 C to 17 C

Wind Speed: 13 mph

Wind direction: West

Tomorrow

Cloudy

Cloudy

Temperature: 9 C to 16 C

Wind Speed: 14 mph

Wind direction: South west

Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.

Scotsman.com provides news, events and sport features from the Edinburgh area. For the best up to date information relating to Edinburgh and the surrounding areas visit us at Scotsman.com regularly or bookmark this page.