Hearts: Final Answer

When all three are fit, who would be your first-choice keeper?

Craig Park, Stockbridge: "My first choice would be Marian Kello with Jamie MacDonald as back-up. I never feel confident when Balogh is in goal. I always feel that a mistake is just around the corner with him."

Joe Wilson, Restalrig: "I think Kello is by far the best goalkeeper at the club at the moment. To be honest, I don't think that there's much difference between Balogh and MacDonald. Neither of them are commanding enough."

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Ken Donaldson, Gilmerton: "I think Kello's form this season has established him as the number one choice of goalkeeper at the club. Jamie hasn't had many chances but he looks more solid than Balogh."

Paul Melrose, Gilmerton: "There's not much between Kello and MacDonald. Balogh isn't a bad goalkeeper either but he isn't as good as the other two. I would consider letting him go in the summer."

Scott Lewis, Inch: "I would like to see MacDonald given a run between now and the end of the season to give him a chance to prove his worth. Kello is better than Balogh but, given a run in the team, MacDonald could prove to be better than both."

Michael Coll, Liberton: "Kello is the best goalkeeper at Hearts. He was in terrific form before picking up his injury. I think he is the first choice in Jim Jefferies' mind as well."

John Preston, Penicuik: "Kello would be my first choice with Balogh as reserve goalkeeper. MacDonald has never really established himself and another season on loan in the First Division might do him some good."

Fiona Adamson, Penicuik: "I think that it should be between Kello and MacDonald to fight it out. Kello is better at the moment but Jamie is still young. He had a great season at Queen of the South and I don't think we've seen the best of him in a Hearts shirt."

Tony Leitch, Morningside: "Balogh makes too many mistakes for me. Our best form this season came when Kello was in goal and I don't think that was coincidence. He is such a good shot-stopper and decent with crosses too."

Adam Finlay, Newington: "Marian Kello is definitely the best keeper. He was in great form when he got injured and he was very unlucky. I think he'll be back in the side when fit."