Pistorius detective charged with 7 attempted murders

South African investigating officer Hilton Botha, who is facing attempted murder charges. Picture: AFP
South African investigating officer Hilton Botha, who is facing attempted murder charges. Picture: AFP
Share this article
Have your say

Hilton Botha, the lead investigator in the case of Oscar Pistorius, has been replaced after he was charged with seven counts of attempted murder.

The announcement by the South African Police Service came on the third day of Pistorius’ bail hearing, as sports giant Nike confirmed it has suspended its contract with the Paralympian.

A Nike statement read: “Nike has suspended its contract with Oscar Pistorius. We believe Oscar Pistorius should be afforded due process and we will continue to monitor the situation closely.”

The company’s now infamous ad showed 26-year-old Pistorius powering out of a set of sprinting blocks, wearing his prosthetic blades, alongside the words ‘I Am The Bullet In The Chamber’.

“Blade Runner” Pistorius has admitted shooting girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp, 29, through the bathroom door, thinking she was a burglar.

Realising his mistake, he broke the door down with a cricket bat and carried her downstairs, he said.

The prosecution claim it was a premeditated murder, but his defence advocate has argued there is no evidence to suggest the athlete’s account of events is untrue.

In a dramatic twist it emerged that lead investigator Hilton Botha has been charged with seven counts of attempted murder relating to an incident in October 2011 and is due to appear in court himself in May with two other police officers, accused of firing shots at a minibus which had seven people inside.

The case was previously dropped but he was charged today, to the surprise of prosecutors in the Pistorius case.

Botha, who gave evidence at Pistorius’ bail hearing today, was summoned back to the witness box today where he was questioned by Magistrate Desmond Nair.

The detective told the court the case against him had previously been dropped, and said he was not drunk and was chasing suspects at the time.

He also admitted he had not yet obtained telephone or financial records for Steenkamp, and was told by Magistrate Nair that there appeared to have been a lack of urgency in getting them.

In a news conference after the bail hearing was adjourned until Friday, National Police Commissioner Riah Phiyega said Botha had been replaced by senior detective Lieutenant General Vineshkumar Moonoo, Divisional Commissioner of the Detective Service.

Describing the “significance”, “importance” and “severity” of the investigation, she said: “This matter shall receive attention at a national level and this is why I am announcing the person who will be leading this.”

Earlier, during the bail hearing’s third day - which was interrupted by fears of a “threat” outside, the star wept as defence advocate Barry Roux summed up his case.

Roux said poor-quality evidence by Botha had exposed disastrous shortcomings in the state’s case.

He said he had been selective with what he said and determined to “bolster the state’s case”, but could not refute Pistorius’ version of what happened.

Roux said Steenkamp staying with the Paralympian was consistent with a loving relationship, and that after she was shot, evidence suggested Pistorius was desperate to save her life.

He said the fact there was no urine in her bladder suggested she had got up to go to the toilet and if Pistorius had shouted about an intruder, it was likely she would have locked the door adding: “The evidence is not that the applicant knew the toilet was locked when he fired the shots.”

Asked if there would be shock if Pistorius was released, Roux said there would be shock if he wasn’t.

Summing up the prosecution case, Gerrie Nel said the onus was not on the state, but on Pistorius, to prove he should be given bail.

He asked if the Paralympian thought: “I’m Oscar Pistorius, I’m a world renowned athlete, that in itself is special”, was an argument for exceptional circumstances and said the star wanted to continue with his life “as if this incident never happened”.

“This total lack of insight and willingness to take responsibility for his deeds increases his flight risk,” he said.

He said Pistorius’ version of events was improbable and his actions that night were indicative of a man ready and willing to fire to kill.

“He fired four shots, not one shot,” he said. “The only reason you fire four shots is to kill. On his own version, he’s bound to be convicted.”