Afghanistan: US soldier’s lawyer ramps up mental health case

John Henry Browne and Emma Scanlan will represent Robert Bales. Picture: AP
John Henry Browne and Emma Scanlan will represent Robert Bales. Picture: AP
Share this article
Have your say

THE American soldier accused of killing 17 Afghan civilians in a shooting rampage suffered a traumatic incident during his second tour in Iraq that triggered “tremendous depression,” his lawyer has claimed in his latest comments on the accusations.

Attorney John Henry Browne said he could not discuss the details of the matter because it remains classified, but he expects the issue to become a focal point in the case against army Staff Sergeant Robert Bales.

“It caused him tremendous depression and anxiety,” Mr Browne said.

The lawyer previously said Bales experienced other major dangers in his deployments, including a serious foot injury and head trauma. In addition, a fellow soldier’s leg had been blown off days before the Afghanistan massacre, he said.

Bales was charged with 17 counts of premeditated murder and other crimes. He is being held at a US military prison at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas.

A defence team representing Bales is in Afghanistan to collect evidence and to interview US soldiers who served with him.

“Everyone they’ve spoken to in the military has nothing but amazingly positive things to say about him,” said Mr Browne, who is not part of the team in Afghanistan.

Due to security concerns, Mr Browne does not think the team will visit the villages where the killings occurred. The investigators are likely to stay in Afghanistan a few more weeks.

Mr Browne again questioned the US government’s case, noting there is no preserved crime scene to assess.

“It’s going to be a difficult case for the prosecution to prove,” he said. “There’s no DNA that I know of. There’s no ballistics that I know of.”

Bales has indicated that he had no recollection of prescription drugs he may have been taking before the shooting – something the lawyer took as an indicator of greater memory problems.

Mr Browne also said his client has a sketchy memory of the night of the shootings. In an interview with the Washington Post, Mr Browne said that Bales remembered the smell of gunfire and of human bodies but not much more.

Mr Browne added his client reported suffering from nightmares, flashbacks of war scenes and persistent headaches after his multiple combat tours. Bales told his legal team that he has long woken up with night sweats and often replays memories of a grisly scene in Iraq that he and his infantry company witnessed several years ago, Mr Browne said.

The lawyer stressed that Bales did not confess and seemed surprised when his weapon was taken away, it was reported. Military officials said Bales was drinking on a southern Afghanistan base on 11 March before creeping away to two villages at night, shooting his victims and setting many of them on fire. Nine were children.

Bales has had incidents involving alcohol and violence in the past.

In 2002, he was arrested for a drunken assault of a security guard at a Tacoma, Washington, casino. That charge was dismissed after Bales completed 20 hours of anger management training.

In 2008, a couple accused an intoxicated Bales of grabbing a woman’s hand and thrusting it toward his crotch before kicking and punching the woman’s boyfriend, according to a police report. Prosecutors declined to pursue that case.