Afghanistan killings: US soldier plans guilty plea

Robert Bales' lawyer said his client was 'broken' by four tours of duty in Afghanistan. Picture: AP
Robert Bales' lawyer said his client was 'broken' by four tours of duty in Afghanistan. Picture: AP
Share this article
Have your say

THE US Army staff sergeant charged with killing 16 villagers in one of the worst atrocities of the Afghanistan war will plead guilty to avoid the death penalty in a deal that requires him to recount the attack for the first time.

Robert Bales was “crazed” and “broken” when he slipped away from his southern Afghanistan outpost in March 2012 and attacked mud-walled compounds in two sleeping villages nearby, his lawyer John Henry Browne said.

However, his client’s mental state did not meet the level of a legal insanity defence, Mr Browne added.

The US Army had been seeking to have Bales executed, and Afghan villagers have demanded it. In interviews last month, relatives of the victims were outraged at the notion Bales might escape the death penalty.

“For this one thing, we would kill 100 American soldiers,” vowed Mohammed Wazir, who had 11 family members killed that night, including his mother and two-year-old daughter. Most of the victims were women and children, and some of the bodies were piled and burned.

The killings drew such angry protests that the US temporarily halted combat operations in Afghanistan. It was three weeks before US investigators could reach the crime scenes.

In Afghanistan yesterday, a family member of a victim reacted angrily to the news that Bales might escape the death penalty.

“This is a shameful act by the Americans. They promised us the death penalty, and now they are going back on their word,” said Baraan Noorzia, whose brother was killed in the massacre.

“A prison sentence doesn’t mean anything,” said Said Jan, whose wife and three other relatives died. “I know we have no power now. But I will become stronger, and if he does not hang, I will have my revenge.”

Any plea deal must be approved by the judge as well as the commanding general at the US base where Bales is being held. A plea hearing is set for 5 June.

“The judge will be asking questions of Sergeant Bales about what he did, what he remembers and his state of mind,” said Mr Browne.

He indicated Bales remembered little from the night of the massacre. However, as further details and records emerged, Bales began to remember what he did, the lawyer said, and he will admit to “very specific facts” about the shootings.

Bales had been drinking contraband alcohol and snorting Valium that was provided to him by another soldier and had been taking steroids before the attack.

Testimony at a hearing last year established that Bales returned to his base between attacking the two villages, woke up a fellow soldier and confessed. The soldier did not believe him and went back to sleep, and Bales left to continue the slaughter.

Mr Browne said his client, who was on his fourth combat deployment, was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and a traumatic brain injury.

“He’s broken, and we broke him,” Mr Browne said.

The massacre raised questions about the toll multiple deployments were taking on US troops. For that reason, many legal experts believed that it was unlikely that he would receive the death penalty. The American military justice system has not executed anyone since 1961.

Bales’ defence team determined after having him examined by psychiatrists that he would not be able to prove any claim of insanity or diminished capacity at the time of the attack, Mr Browne said.

The lawyer acknowledged the plea deal could inflame tensions in Afghanistan and said he was disappointed the case has not done more to focus public opinion on the war.


Man accused of killing 16 ‘cracked after friend lost leg in bomb blast’